Skip to content

Have the Faith of God

A reflection for the Feast of St. Gregory the Wonderworker, Bishop and Confessor — S. Gregorii Thaumaturgi Episcopi et Confessoris, III classis (17 November), Feria III infra Hebdomadam VI quæ superfuit post Epiphaniam

Sometime around the year 233, two young brothers from Neocæsarea in Pontus set out for Berytus, in Phœnicia, where there was a famous school of Roman law. The elder was called Theodore. He was about twenty, of a wealthy pagan family, and his mother meant him for the bar. On the way they turned aside to Cæsarea in Palestine, on an errand for their brother-in-law, and there they met a teacher named Origen. They never went to Berytus. Theodore stayed at Cæsarea for five years, and when he left he was a Christian, he had a new name, Gregory, and he had learned from Origen to read all the wisdom of the Greeks as a road that leads to Christ.

Before he went home, he stood up in the presence of his master and gave a farewell address, which we still have. In it he says that Origen’s teaching fell upon his soul like a spark, and kindled in him a love for the Word, who draws all things to Himself, and for the man who was the Word’s friend and advocate (Oratio panegyrica in Origenem 6). He compares himself to Adam leaving Paradise, and to the Jews going into Babylon. He did not want to leave. He wanted, as he said, to spend his life in study and in quiet.

God had other plans. Back in Neocæsarea, the bishop of the neighbouring see of Amasea, Phædimus, resolved to make him bishop of his native city. Gregory fled into the wilderness. Phædimus, says St. Gregory of Nyssa, who wrote his life a century later, consecrated him anyway, from three days’ journey away, dedicating to God a man who was not even present (De vita Gregorii Thaumaturgi, PG 46). Gregory came out of hiding and submitted. Tradition says that when he took up his see there were seventeen Christians in the city, and that when he died, some thirty years later, there were seventeen pagans. The Greeks called him Thaumatourgos, the Wonderworker, and the name has stayed with him in East and West alike. The Byzantine Church keeps his feast on this same day.

The Mass is from the Common of a Confessor Bishop, Statuit, but with a proper Gospel; the vestments are white. The Introit sings of the covenant: “The Lord made to him a covenant of peace, and made him a prince: that the dignity of priesthood should be to him for ever.” The Gradual takes up the Epistle: Ecce sacerdos magnus, “Behold a great priest, who in his days pleased God.” The Offertory gives the Lord’s own word over David: “I have found David my servant, with my holy oil I have anointed him.” And the Gospel, chosen for this saint and no other, is the word of Our Lord about the mountain cast into the sea.

It is Tuesday of the sixth week after the Epiphany, resumed in these last weeks of the year. On Sunday the Church read the parable of the mustard seed, the least of all seeds, that grows into a tree where the birds of the air come and dwell. Our Lord used that same seed, elsewhere, as the measure of the faith that moves mountains: “If you have faith as a grain of mustard seed, you shall say to this mountain, Remove from hence hither, and it shall remove” (Matt. 17:19). The Church that sang of the mustard seed on Sunday sings today of the mountain. Between them stands the bishop who began with seventeen.

I. Ecce sacerdos magnus: the Epistle

“Behold a great priest, who in his days pleased God, and was found just: and in the time of wrath he was made a reconciliation. There was not found the like to him, who kept the law of the most High. Therefore by an oath the Lord made him to increase among his people. He gave him the blessing of all nations, and confirmed his covenant upon his head. He acknowledged him in his blessings: he preserved for him his mercy: and he found grace before the eyes of the Lord. He glorified him in the sight of kings, and gave him a crown of glory. He made an everlasting covenant with him, and gave him a great priesthood: and made him blessed in glory. To execute the office of the priesthood, and to have praise in his name, and to offer him a worthy incense for an odour of sweetness.” (Ecclus. 44:16-27; 45:3-20)

The Epistle is not a single passage but a mosaic. The Church has taken the great hymn of the Book of Ecclesiasticus, “Let us now praise men of renown, and our fathers in their generation” (Ecclus. 44:1), and gathered from it the lines spoken of Noe, of Abraham, of Moses, and of Aaron, and joined them into one portrait of a priest. It is as though the Church were saying: every holy bishop is all of these at once. He is Noe, found just in a corrupt generation. He is Abraham, through whom the blessing passes to the nations. He is Moses, glorified before kings. He is Aaron, who offers incense before the Lord.

In the time of wrath he was made a reconciliation. In the Hebrew sense of Ecclesiasticus, this is said of Noe, who in the flood was a remnant through whom the world was renewed. The Vulgate’s reconciliatio gives the line its priestly ring, for to reconcile is the work of a priest. St. Paul says it plainly: God “hath given to us the ministry of reconciliation” (2 Cor. 5:18). Gregory’s times were times of wrath. The persecution of Decius broke over Pontus in 250, and Gregory, knowing the weakness of his young flock, counselled them to flee rather than to tempt the persecutors, and fled himself to the hills, praying for those who were taken (Gregory of Nyssa, De vita). Plague followed the persecution. Then, a few years later, came the Goths, who raided Pontus and carried off captives, and some Christians of Neocæsarea joined the raiders in plundering their own neighbours. Gregory’s Canonical Epistle, written in that crisis, is one of the oldest documents of the Church’s penitential discipline. It weighs each offence, sets a penance for each, and sets out the stages by which the fallen are led back to the altar (Epistula canonica, PG 10). The Wonderworker was also, and first, a confessor of sins and a reconciler of sinners.

There was not found the like to him, who kept the law of the most High. The Church sings this line in the Gradual of every confessor bishop, and it might seem extravagant. How can each of them be without equal? Durandus and the old liturgical commentators answer that each saint is unique in the particular grace God gave him, so that the Church may say of each, in his own gift, that none was like him. For Gregory the gift is plain. St. Basil the Great, writing about a hundred years after his death, sets him at the head of the great teachers of the faith, and calls him a great luminary of the Church, who by the power of the Spirit had authority over demons, turned rivers from their course, and dried up a lake that had become a cause of strife between two brothers, so that in his time he was called a second Moses even by the enemies of the faith (De Spiritu Sancto 29.74).

He glorified him in the sight of kings. This is said of Moses, who stood before Pharao (Ecclus. 45:3). Basil’s title for Gregory, another Moses, shows that the Church saw Gregory through exactly this text. Moses was the man who spoke face to face with God, worked signs before Pharao, and gave the law to the people. Gregory, says his Nyssene biographer, was the man to whom the faith was given on the mountain before he began to teach it.

For before he preached a single sermon in Neocæsarea, Gregory of Nyssa tells us, the new bishop passed a night troubled about the mystery of the Trinity, for heretics had obscured it, and he did not wish to teach anything he had not received. In a vision there appeared to him an old man of great dignity, and with him a lady of more than human beauty. The lady told the old man, whom she called John the Evangelist, to reveal to the young bishop the mystery of the true faith. And St. John spoke to him a short and exact confession of the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost, the Trinity perfect, undivided, and unaltering. Gregory wrote it down at once, and preached from it ever after; and Nyssa says that the autograph was still kept in the church of Neocæsarea in his own day (De vita, PG 46). It is the first recorded apparition of the Mother of God in Christian history. Whatever one judges of the details, the Expositio fidei that bears Gregory’s name is a genuine third-century confession, older than Nicæa, and it is Trinitarian through and through. The bishop who would move mountains began by receiving a creed. The law of the Most High was given him before he kept it.

And to offer him a worthy incense for an odour of sweetness. The portrait closes with Aaron at the altar. All the rest, the blessing of nations, the glory before kings, the crown, is ordered to this: that the priest should offer. St. Thomas teaches that the priest is properly the mediator between God and the people, who carries the people’s offerings up to God, and brings God’s gifts down to the people (Summa Theologiæ III, q. 22). That is the shape of every bishop’s life, and it is the shape of Gregory’s. He went up to the mountain to receive the faith; he came down to give it.

II. Habete fidem Dei: the Gospel

“At that time, Jesus answering, saith to them: Have the faith of God. Amen I say to you, that whosoever shall say to this mountain, Be thou removed and be cast into the sea, and shall not stagger in his heart, but believe, that whatsoever he saith shall be done; it shall be done unto him. Therefore I say unto you, all things, whatsoever you ask when ye pray, believe that you shall receive; and they shall come unto you.” (Mark 11:22-24)

Why this Gospel? The Church gave St. Gregory a proper Gospel because of a story that the West learned from Rufinus of Aquileia, who added it to his Latin version of Eusebius’s Ecclesiastical History. Gregory wished to build a church, says Rufinus, but the only level ground was hemmed in by a hill that left no room. Gregory went out at night and prayed, and in the morning the hill had drawn back far enough to leave space for the foundations (Rufinus, Historia ecclesiastica, additions to Book VII). Venerable Bede, commenting on this very verse of St. Mark, tells the same story, and then asks the question every reader asks: why, if faith can move mountains, do we not see the apostles moving them? He answers that they did greater things, which are not written, and that a sign is given only when it is needed; Gregory needed room for a church, and so the mountain moved (In Marci evangelium expositio III, on 11:23). Nyssa’s Life gives a nearer and more certain wonder: a pagan temple priest, demanding a sign, asked Gregory to move a great stone, and Gregory commanded it and it moved, and the priest left his idols and became a Christian (De vita, PG 46). The mountain of the Gospel and the stone of Pontus belong together.

Have the faith of God. The words come in the morning after the cursing of the barren fig tree. Peter has just said, astonished, “Rabbi, behold the fig tree, which thou didst curse, is withered away” (Mark 11:21), and this is Our Lord’s answer. The phrase is strange in Greek and in Latin: habete fidem Dei, have God’s faith. Bede and the older commentators read it simply as faith in God; but the genitive allows a second sense, which the Fathers never forgot: faith that comes from God, the faith He gives. Faith is not a muscle we flex. It is a gift, and the one who receives it has, in a real sense, a share in God’s own certainty. St. Thomas says that the act of faith is an act of the intellect moved by the will under grace, and that its certainty rests not on what we see but on the truth of God who reveals (Summa Theologiæ II-II, q. 4; cf. q. 6). The faith that moves mountains is never ours alone. That is why Gregory, before he moved any stone, asked to be given the Creed.

Whosoever shall say to this mountain. Our Lord and the disciples are on the road from Bethania to Jerusalem, and this mountain, monti huic, is most likely the Mount of Olives itself, standing over them as He speaks, or perhaps the Temple mount before them. The sea in sight is the Dead Sea, far below. The Fathers did not stop at the literal. St. Jerome, commenting on the same saying in St. Matthew, says that the mountain is the devil, swollen with pride, and that the faith of the saints casts him down into the sea, that is, into the abyss (Commentarius in Matthæum III, on 21:21). Bede follows him and adds that the mountain may also stand for the pride of any soul, which faith uproots and throws into the depths of humility (In Marci evangelium expositio III). St. Augustine sees something more: a mountain cast into the sea is the Church carried from Israel into the sea of the nations, and the Lord Himself, “the mountain of the house of the Lord” (Isa. 2:2), preached to the Gentiles by the apostles’ faith (cf. Enarrationes in Psalmos 45.6).

Each of these readings fits the bishop of Neocæsarea. He cast out demons from the temple where he slept, says Nyssa, so that the oracle there fell silent. He carried the Gospel into a city that was almost wholly pagan. And he moved the mountain that stands in every soul, the hill of self-will, by the humility with which he fled the episcopate and then accepted it.

And shall not stagger in his heart. Et non hæsitaverit in corde suo. The word is hesitate, be divided, dispute with oneself. St. James uses the same image: “Let him ask in faith, nothing wavering. For he that wavereth is like a wave of the sea, which is moved and carried about by the wind. Therefore let not that man think that he shall receive any thing of the Lord” (James 1:6-7). St. John Chrysostom, preaching on the fig tree, says that Our Lord here puts everything into the hands of faith and prayer, and teaches His disciples that if they pray with an undivided heart they will do not only what He did to the fig tree but greater things (Homiliæ in Matthæum 67 [68]). A divided heart is a heart that half believes and half does not, that asks and at the same time protects itself against the disappointment of not receiving. The Wonderworker’s whole life is an argument against that kind of prayer.

All things, whatsoever you ask when ye pray, believe that you shall receive. Here the reader must be careful, and the Fathers are careful. This is not a promise that God will give whatever we happen to want if only we want it hard enough. St. Augustine, writing to the widow Proba on prayer, says that we must ask above all for the happy life, which is God Himself, and that every other petition is to be measured by that one; God, in His mercy, sometimes refuses what we ask in order to give what we need (Epistula 130.8-14). St. Thomas sets down the conditions under which prayer is infallibly heard: when we ask for ourselves, for things necessary to salvation, with devotion, and with perseverance (Summa Theologiæ II-II, q. 83). The prayer that moves mountains is the prayer that asks first for faith, and then for whatever God wills to give through it.

And there is a further condition, which St. Mark records in the very next verse, though the Missal’s Gospel stops just short of it: “And when you shall stand to pray, forgive, if you have aught against any man; that your Father also, who is in heaven, may forgive you your sins” (Mark 11:25). Faith that moves mountains cannot dwell in a heart that will not forgive. The Wonderworker, who was able to dry up a lake to end a quarrel between two brothers, knew that the deeper miracle was always reconciliation.

III. The Mass as a whole: the faith received and the faith that moves

St. Thomas built the Summa Theologiæ on the great circle of exitus and reditus: all things come forth from God, and all things return to Him through Christ, who as man is our way to God (Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue). Today’s Mass traces that circle in the life of a bishop.

The going-forth begins with God. “The Lord made to him a covenant of peace.” Statuit, sings the Introit: He established. The covenant is God’s act before it is ever the bishop’s. “With my holy oil I have anointed him,” the Offertory says; “I have found David my servant.” God goes out to find His servant, as He found the young law student at Cæsarea and turned him from his road; as Phædimus, from three days away, laid him under the yoke he had fled. Then the faith goes forth from God to the bishop on the night of the vision: the Creed spoken by the beloved disciple, at the bidding of the Mother of God. And from the bishop it goes out to the people: from the seventeen to the whole city of Neocæsarea, and from Neocæsarea, through Basil’s grandmother Macrina, who as a girl had learned the faith from Gregory’s disciples, to the Cappadocian Fathers who would defend the Holy Trinity against the Arians (Basil, Epistulæ 204.6, 207.4). The exitus of the faith is a chain of hands.

The return is the offering. “To execute the office of the priesthood, and to have praise in his name, and to offer him a worthy incense.” Everything God gave the bishop he gave back in sacrifice: his learning, which he laid at the feet of the Word; his quiet, which he surrendered to the episcopate; his wonders, which turned men from idols to the living God. And the Gospel shows what carries this return: faith and prayer. “Whatsoever you ask when ye pray, believe that you shall receive.” Prayer is the movement of the soul back to God, the reditus in its simplest form. The faith that came down to Gregory on the night of the vision went back up from him in prayer, and wherever it passed, mountains moved.

The two readings, then, say one thing. The Epistle shows a priest whom God has made great; the Gospel shows how. Not by his own strength, not by his learning, not even by his virtue alone, but by the faith of God, received and not doubted. Gregory’s miracles were never displays. Each one, as Nyssa tells them, served a single end: to make room for the Church, to end a quarrel, to free a soul from an idol, to keep a river from drowning a town. The mountain moves so that the church may be built. The sign serves the sacrifice.

IV. The Collects

Da, quæsumus, omnipotens Deus: ut beati Gregorii Confessoris tui atque Pontificis veneranda solemnitas, et devotionem nobis augeat et salutem.

“Grant, we beseech Thee, almighty God, that the venerable solemnity of blessed Gregory, Thy Confessor and Bishop, may increase in us both devotion and salvation.”

The Collect is from the Common, and it asks for very little and very much. It does not ask that we may work wonders like the Wonderworker. It asks for two things only: devotio and salus. Devotion, says St. Thomas, is the will’s promptness to give itself to the service of God (Summa Theologiæ II-II, q. 82). Salvation is the end of that service. The prayer is a faithful reading of the Gospel: the faith that moves mountains is first the faith that moves the will to God, and its last fruit is not the moved mountain but the saved soul.

Sancti tui, quæsumus, Domine, nos ubique lætificent: ut, dum eorum merita recolimus, patrocinia sentiamus.

“May Thy Saints, we beseech Thee, O Lord, everywhere make us glad: that while we call to mind their merits, we may feel their patronage.”

Ubique: everywhere. The Secret asks that the saints gladden us not only on their feast but in every place. Gregory’s own people at Neocæsarea did exactly this; Basil says they kept his customs and words unchanged for a century, adding nothing to them, as if he were still among them (De Spiritu Sancto 29.74).

Præsta, quæsumus, omnipotens Deus: ut, de perceptis muneribus gratias exhibentes, intercedente beato Gregorio Confessore tuo atque Pontifice, beneficia potiora sumamus.

“Grant, we beseech Thee, almighty God, that giving thanks for the gifts we have received, we may, by the intercession of blessed Gregory, Thy Confessor and Bishop, obtain still greater benefits.”

The Postcommunion is the Gospel turned into thanksgiving. We have received; we give thanks; and, believing, we ask for more, beneficia potiora, greater gifts. This is the prayer that does not stagger in its heart.

V. A word for practice

Examine. What is the mountain in front of me? Is there a sin, a habit, a fear, a grudge, that I have stopped asking God to move because I no longer believe He will? When I pray, do I pray with an undivided heart, or do I ask and at the same moment protect myself against not being heard? Is there someone I have not forgiven, so that my prayer goes up with a weight upon it? And do I know the faith I profess? Could I state, clearly and without error, what the Church believes about the Holy Trinity?

Do. Pray the Creed today slowly, as Gregory received his: not as a formula, but as a gift handed down to you from the apostles. If there is a quarrel in your family or among your friends, take one step toward ending it this week. Bring to God, in faith, the one intention you have most nearly given up on, and ask again, believing that you shall receive. If you have the means, read a few pages of Gregory’s farewell address to Origen, which is one of the most beautiful accounts in antiquity of a soul being drawn to Christ through a teacher.

Pray. The Collect of the day, asking for devotion and salvation. Then the prayer of the father of the possessed boy, which is the prayer of every divided heart: “I do believe, Lord: help my unbelief” (Mark 9:23).

Aspiration. Habete fidem Dei. “Have the faith of God.”

Devote. Honour the Mother of God, who, in the oldest account of her appearing, came to a young bishop not to give him a message of her own but to see that he was taught the truth about her Son and His Father and the Holy Ghost. Pray a decade of the Rosary today for bishops, that they may receive and hand on the faith whole. And since it is November, the month of the Holy Souls, remember the faithful departed of your own family, the hands through which the faith came down to you, as it came to the Cappadocians through Macrina from the disciples of St. Gregory.


If you wish to go deeper: the Lives of the Saints path tells the story of St. Gregory the Wonderworker: his conversion under Origen at Cæsarea, his flight from the episcopate, the vision of the Creed, the wonders recorded by St. Gregory of Nyssa, and his conduct in persecution, plague, and invasion. The Theology and Doctrine path takes up his Expositio fidei as a pre-Nicene witness to the Holy Trinity, and treats St. Thomas’s doctrine of faith and of the conditions of efficacious prayer. The Church History path considers the Church of Pontus in the third century, the Council of Antioch against Paul of Samosata, at which Gregory sat, and the line that runs from Gregory to Macrina the Elder and the Cappadocian Fathers. The Sacred Liturgy path considers the Common of a Confessor Bishop, Statuit, and the ancient practice of assigning proper Gospels to saints whose lives illustrate them.

Sources. Scripture is cited from the Douay-Rheims, with the Vulgate. The Fathers are given in paraphrase with their loci: St. Gregory Thaumaturgus, Oratio panegyrica in Origenem 6, Expositio fidei, Epistula canonica (PG 10); St. Gregory of Nyssa, De vita Gregorii Thaumaturgi (PG 46); St. Basil the Great, De Spiritu Sancto 29.74, Epistulæ 204.6 and 207.4; Rufinus of Aquileia, Historia ecclesiastica, additions to Book VII; St. Jerome, Commentarius in Matthæum III (on 21:21); St. Augustine, Enarrationes in Psalmos 45, Epistula 130; St. John Chrysostom, Homiliæ in Matthæum 67 [68]; St. Bede the Venerable, In Marci evangelium expositio III (on 11:22-24). St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue; II-II, qq. 4, 6, 82, 83; III, q. 22. For St. Gregory: the Roman Martyrology; Butler’s Lives of the Saints.

Ecce sacerdos magnus, qui in diebus suis placuit Deo.

Share the Post:

Related Posts