In Dedicatione Basilicarum Ss. Apostolorum Petri et Pauli — on the eighteenth day of November, III classis
Tu es Petrus, et super hanc petram ædificabo Ecclesiam meam, et tibi dabo claves regni cælorum. “Thou art Peter; and upon this rock I will build my church… And I will give to thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven.” (Matt. 16:18-19) — inscribed around the drum of the dome of St. Peter’s
I. Two churches over two graves
Nine days ago the Church kept the dedication of the Lateran, the cathedral of the Pope and the mother of all churches. Today she keeps the dedication of two other Roman churches: St. Peter’s on the Vatican hill and St. Paul’s on the road to Ostia, outside the walls.
The Lateran was built over nothing in particular. It stands where it does because an emperor owned the land. These two basilicas stand where they do for one reason only: each was built over the grave of an apostle. The Lateran is the church of Peter’s chair. St. Peter’s and St. Paul’s are the churches of the apostles’ bodies. The one shows where the authority of the Roman Church sits; the others show what it rests on, the blood of the two men who founded it.
So this entry, like the Lateran’s, has no single life to tell. Its subject is two graves and the churches raised over them: how the apostles died, how the Roman Christians marked the places, what Constantine built, how the old churches fell and were rebuilt, what the excavations of the last century found, and what the Church means when she sets her altars on the bones of the saints. As always, what is documented is kept apart from what is reliably reported, and both from what pious tradition has handed down. The lives of Peter and Paul themselves belong to their own feasts; here they appear as the foundation stones.
II. How the apostles died
The witnesses. The New Testament does not tell us how Peter and Paul died. The Acts of the Apostles leaves Paul under house arrest in Rome, preaching freely, and ends there (Acts 28:30-31). Our Lord foretold Peter’s death in words that St. John says were spoken “signifying by what death he should glorify God”: “when thou shalt be old, thou shalt stretch forth thy hands, and another shall gird thee, and lead thee whither thou wouldst not” (John 21:18-19). Paul, writing to Timothy from his last imprisonment, says: “I am even now ready to be sacrificed: and the time of my dissolution is at hand. I have fought a good fight, I have finished my course, I have kept the faith” (2 Tim. 4:6-7).
The earliest Christian writers fill in what Scripture leaves out. Writing from Rome about the year 96, Pope St. Clement held up Peter and Paul as “the greatest and most righteous pillars” of the Church, who were persecuted and contended unto death. Peter, he says, bore his witness and went to the place of glory that was his due. Paul, after being seven times in chains and preaching to the limit of the West, bore his witness before rulers and so departed from the world (1 Clement 5). He joins them at once to “a great multitude of the elect” who suffered among the Romans, which is to say the victims of Nero (1 Clement 6). About the year 107, St. Ignatius of Antioch, on his way to the beasts, wrote to the Roman Christians that he did not give them orders “as Peter and Paul did” (Ad Romanos 4.3), a phrase that assumes both apostles had been among them. About 170, Bishop Dionysius of Corinth wrote to Pope Soter that Peter and Paul had both taught in Italy and were martyred there at the same time (in Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica II.25.8). St. Irenæus calls the Roman Church the one “founded and constituted by the two most glorious apostles, Peter and Paul” (Adversus Hæreses III.3.2).
That both apostles died as martyrs in Rome, under Nero, is Tier 1: it rests on witnesses who wrote within a lifetime of the events and in the city where they happened. The year is not certain. Tacitus records the great fire of July 64 and the savage punishment of the Christians that followed it, some crucified, some sewn in skins and torn by dogs, some burned as torches in the gardens of Nero (Annales XV.44). Many scholars place Peter’s death in that persecution, in 64 or soon after; the Roman tradition gives the year 67. Both are honest positions.
The manner of their deaths. Tertullian, writing about 200, says that at Rome Peter suffered a passion like the Lord’s, and Paul was crowned with the death of John, that is, by beheading (De præscriptione hæreticorum 36). Origen, quoted by Eusebius, adds that Peter was crucified head downward, at his own request (in Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica III.1.2). Paul, a Roman citizen, could not be crucified; he died by the sword. These details are Tier 2: very early, consistent, and never contradicted.
The places. Peter died, by the Roman tradition, in the circus of Gaius and Nero at the foot of the Vatican hill, across the Tiber from the city, and was buried in the cemetery that lined the road beside it. The Egyptian obelisk that stood in the middle of that circus is the one that stands today in the square before St. Peter’s; Pope Sixtus V had it moved there in 1586. It is the one monument in Rome that very probably saw the Apostle die. Paul was beheaded, by tradition, at a place called Aquæ Salviæ, on the road south of the city, and buried two miles closer to the walls, beside the road to Ostia. The connection of Peter’s death with the circus is Tier 2. The site at Aquæ Salviæ is Tier 2 as an ancient tradition. The story that his head struck the ground three times and three fountains sprang up, which gave the place its later name of Tre Fontane, is Tier 3.
Quo vadis. St. Ambrose tells the best-loved story of Peter’s end. When the persecution broke out, the Christians of Rome begged Peter to save himself, and he left the city by night. At the gate he met Christ coming in, and asked Him, “Lord, where are You going?” Christ answered, “I am coming to be crucified again.” Peter understood that the Lord meant to suffer again in His servant, and he turned back to his death (Sermo contra Auxentium 13). The story is older than Ambrose; it is found in the apocryphal Acts of Peter of the late second century. It is Tier 3. It is also the truest commentary there is on John 21:18.
III. The trophies
Gaius. About the year 200, as the companion reflection for today recalls, a Roman priest named Gaius answered a heretic who boasted of the apostolic tombs of Asia. “I can show you the trophies of the apostles,” he wrote. “If you will go to the Vatican or to the Ostian Way, you will find the trophies of those who founded this Church” (in Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica II.25.7). A trophy was a victory monument. Gaius meant memorials raised over the places where Peter and Paul lay. By his day, then, both graves were marked, known, and visited.
The Vatican trophy. In the excavations beneath St. Peter’s, described below, the archæologists found what Gaius was talking about. In a small open space in the hillside cemetery, against a wall plastered red, stood a modest shrine: two little columns holding up a stone slab, with a niche in the wall above, built over a poor grave in the earth. Brick stamps in a drain beside it date it to about the year 160. The pagan tombs around it were rich; the space beneath the shrine was poor, and the burials crowded close around it, as Christians later crowded their graves around the martyrs. The existence of this shrine, of its date, and of its veneration from the second century on is Tier 1. That it marks the grave of St. Peter is the plain meaning of all the evidence, and the Church has taught it since Gaius.
The memorial on the Appian Way. One piece of evidence has puzzled historians for centuries. The Roman calendar of the year 354, which preserves the oldest list of the city’s martyr feasts, gives for 29 June: “Peter at the Catacombs, and Paul on the Ostian Way, in the consulship of Tuscus and Bassus,” that is, in the year 258. “The Catacombs” was the cemetery on the Appian Way where the church of St. Sebastian now stands. Under that church the excavators found a third-century hall for funeral meals, its walls covered with scratched prayers to Peter and Paul in Latin and Greek: “Paul and Peter, pray for Victor,” and many like it. Pope St. Damasus later set up a verse inscription there saying that the saints had once “dwelt” in that place.
The cult of both apostles on the Appian Way in the third century is Tier 1. What it means is not settled. Some hold that the relics were moved there for safety during the persecution of Valerian in 258 and later returned; others that 258 is the date when a common feast of the two apostles began to be kept there, at a memorial and not a grave. St. Ambrose’s hymn for the apostles’ feast, Apostolorum passio, speaks of the crowds of Rome keeping the festival “on three roads”: the Vatican, the Ostian Way, and the Appian. The translation of the relics is Tier 2 at best. What is beyond doubt is that from the third century the Roman Christians honoured Peter and Paul together, on one day, and have never stopped.
IV. What Constantine built
St. Peter’s. After his victory in 312, Constantine resolved to build a great church over Peter’s grave. It was the hardest site in Rome. The trophy stood on the slope of a hill, in the middle of a crowded cemetery still in use. To build there, the emperor’s engineers had to cut away part of the hill on one side, fill in the cemetery on the other, and bury the tombs of wealthy pagan families under tons of earth, against every instinct of Roman law and custom, which held tombs inviolable. No one would have chosen that ground for any reason except one: the church had to stand exactly over that grave. The shrine of the second century was left standing, enclosed in a casing of marble and porphyry, and became the centre of the apse. Everything in the building was laid out from it.
The basilica that rose there, begun probably around 320, was enormous: five aisles, a transept, and a great atrium before the doors. It was built less as a parish church than as a covered cemetery and a place of pilgrimage, and for twelve centuries it was the goal of pilgrims from the whole of Christendom.
What the Breviary tells. The lessons of today’s Office give the Roman tradition of its founding. They say that Constantine, on the eighth day after his baptism, came to the Vatican, laid aside his crown, and threw himself on the ground in tears; that he took a spade and broke the earth himself, and carried away twelve baskets of soil in honour of the twelve apostles, to mark out the church; and that Pope St. Sylvester dedicated it on the eighteenth of November, as he had dedicated the Lateran on the ninth. They add that Sylvester anointed a stone altar there and decreed that from then on altars should be of stone, and that Constantine built a church on the Ostian Way in honour of St. Paul, which Sylvester also dedicated, and endowed both with estates and gifts.
These lessons are read with reverence, and they need sorting. That Constantine built both churches is Tier 1; the Liber Pontificalis lists his gifts to both. The dedication by Sylvester, who died in 335, is Tier 2, and the day of 18 November is a Roman tradition not attested by any document of the fourth century. The twelve baskets are Tier 3. The baptism by Sylvester belongs to the legend of the Acts of Sylvester, already treated in the entry for the Lateran: Constantine was in fact baptised on his deathbed in 337. The decree about stone altars, as also noted there, describes a law that grew gradually.
St. Paul’s. Constantine’s church on the Ostian Way was much smaller. It stood close to the road, and the road left little room; its apse faced the highway and the grave lay just inside. Within fifty years it could no longer hold the crowds. In 384 or 386 three emperors, Valentinian II, Theodosius and Arcadius, wrote to the prefect of Rome, Sallustius, ordering a new and far greater basilica to be built, and the letter survives (Collectio Avellana 3). The new church was turned around so that it faced the other way, with the road behind the apse, which gave room for a vast nave of five aisles. Pope Siricius dedicated it about 390; his name was carved on one of its columns, which still stands. The emperor Honorius finished the building. In the next century, after damage by fire and earthquake, St. Leo the Great restored it, and the empress Galla Placidia paid for the mosaic of the great arch over the altar. Its inscription recorded that Theodosius began the hall and Honorius completed it, a hall made holy by the body of Paul, teacher of the world. Until the new St. Peter’s was built it was the largest church in Rome.
Above the columns of the nave ran a series of portraits of the Popes, one after another from St. Peter, begun in the fifth century and continued ever since. They are still there, renewed after the fire, and they still continue.
V. The Vatican through the centuries
The heart of Christendom. For more than a thousand years the old St. Peter’s was the great church of the West. Kings came to it as pilgrims. On Christmas Day of the year 800, Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne emperor before its altar. Pilgrims from England kept their own quarter beside it, the Schola Saxonum. In the year 846 Saracen raiders came up the Tiber and plundered both basilicas, which stood outside the city walls; Pope St. Leo IV then built a wall around the Vatican, and the district within it is still called the Leonine City. In 1300 Pope Boniface VIII proclaimed the first Holy Year, and the pilgrims who came to Rome were bound to visit the two apostolic basilicas; the visit to St. Peter’s and St. Paul’s remained at the heart of every Jubilee after.
The rebuilding. By the fifteenth century Constantine’s church was eleven hundred years old, its walls were leaning, and its roof was failing. Popes Nicholas V and Paul II began repairs. Pope Julius II decided instead to replace it altogether, and on 18 April 1506 he laid the foundation stone of a new basilica designed by Bramante. The work took a hundred and twenty years. Michelangelo, in old age, designed the great dome, which Giacomo della Porta completed in 1590. Carlo Maderno lengthened the nave to the west and built the façade, finished in 1612. The old church was pulled down piece by piece as the new one rose around the grave.
Honesty requires one more fact. To pay for the building, Pope Leo X proclaimed an indulgence in 1515, and its preaching in Germany by the Dominican John Tetzel, with abuses that the Church herself later condemned, was the occasion of Martin Luther’s theses of October 1517. The greatest church in Christendom was built in the years when Christendom was torn in two. The doctrine of indulgences was not false; the manner in which this one was preached was a scandal, and the Council of Trent abolished the office of the indulgence-preacher (Session XXI, Decretum de reformatione, chapter 9).
The consecration. Pope Urban VIII consecrated the new basilica on 18 November 1626, choosing the anniversary of the old dedication. Bernini then completed it from within and without: the bronze canopy over the papal altar, raised directly over the grave (1624-1633); the great reliquary of the Chair of Peter in the apse (1657-1666); and the colonnade that embraces the square like two arms (1656-1667). Before the altar, steps lead down to the Confessio, the open space before the grave, where lamps burn day and night. In a niche there, directly above the old trophy, the pallia are kept which the Pope sends to every new metropolitan archbishop. The bond of every archbishop to the Roman See is thus laid, literally, on the tomb of Peter.
VI. St. Paul’s outside the Walls
The abbey. St. Paul’s stood alone in the countryside, two miles from the gates, and from early times monks kept its services. In 936 the ruler of Rome, Alberic, invited St. Odo, abbot of Cluny, to reform the monasteries of the city, and St. Paul’s was among them. The Roman Martyrology commemorates St. Odo on this very day, the anniversary of his death at Tours in 942, a fitting coincidence for the basilica he renewed. In the eleventh century the abbey was in the care of the archdeacon Hildebrand, the future Pope St. Gregory VII, and in 1070 great bronze doors were cast for it in Constantinople, inlaid with scenes of the life of Christ and the apostles. Benedictine monks keep the basilica still. In the thirteenth century the Vassalletto family of marble-workers built the cloister, and in 1285 Arnolfo di Cambio raised the Gothic canopy over the altar.
The fire. On the night of 15 July 1823, workmen repairing the roof left a brazier burning. By morning the basilica that had stood for fourteen hundred years was a ruin. The roof had fallen into the nave, the columns had cracked in the heat, and most of the mosaics and the portraits of the Popes were lost. Pope Pius VII lay dying that summer; he had been a Benedictine monk of St. Paul’s in his youth. It is reported that those around him kept the news from him, and he died on 20 August without knowing. That detail is Tier 2.
The rebuilding. Leo XII resolved that the basilica should be rebuilt exactly on its ancient plan and appealed to the whole Catholic world for help. The gifts came from everywhere, and from beyond the Catholic world: the Viceroy of Egypt sent columns of alabaster, and the Tsar of Russia blocks of malachite for the altars of the transept. Four Popes carried the work forward: Leo XII, Pius VIII, Gregory XVI, who consecrated the altar of the transept in 1840, and Pius IX. On 8 December 1854 Pius IX defined the dogma of the Immaculate Conception in St. Peter’s before some two hundred bishops and cardinals gathered in Rome. Two days later, on 10 December, with the same prelates around him, he consecrated the rebuilt St. Paul’s, and ordered that its anniversary should continue to be kept on 18 November with St. Peter’s, as it had always been. Their names are recorded on tablets in the apse.
What survived the fire was kept: the canopy of Arnolfo, the column of Siricius, much of the mosaic of the great arch, the cloister, and parts of the bronze doors. The church that stands today is new, and it is also, by design, the old church again.
VII. What the excavations found
Beneath St. Peter’s. Pope Pius XI died in February 1939 having asked to be buried as near as possible to St. Peter. When workmen lowered the floor of the crypt to prepare his tomb, they broke into the Roman cemetery beneath. His successor, Pius XII, ordered a systematic excavation, carried out in secret during the Second World War by a small team of archæologists. They found the street of tombs that Constantine had buried, many of them pagan, a few Christian, one with the oldest known mosaic of Christ as the sun. And under the papal altar, beneath the altars of Clement VIII, Callistus II and Gregory the Great, they found the Constantinian monument and, within it, the trophy of the second century, exactly where the tradition said it would be.
In his radio message at Christmas 1950, Pius XII announced to the world that the tomb of the Prince of the Apostles had been found. He was careful in what he claimed. The tomb, he said, had been identified; whether the remains of the Apostle could be identified with certainty was a separate question.
The bones. The later story is more complicated. Beside the trophy stood a wall covered with scratched Christian graffiti, and inside it a small marble-lined repository. The scholar Margherita Guarducci, who spent years deciphering the graffiti, argued that bones taken from that repository during the excavation were those of a robust man of sixty to seventy years, wrapped in cloth of purple and gold, and that a fragment of the red wall carried the Greek words Petros eni, “Peter is here.” On 26 June 1968 Pope Paul VI announced that the relics of St. Peter had been identified “in a way we can consider convincing.” The identification of the bones is Tier 2. It has been both defended and disputed by serious scholars, and the Church has not asked anyone to treat it as of faith. The location of the grave beneath the altar is the firmer fact, and it is what the Roman Church has always taught.
Beneath St. Paul’s. Between 2002 and 2006, archæologists of the Vatican Museums excavated beneath the high altar of St. Paul’s. Under the altar they found a marble slab carved in the fourth century with the words PAULO APOSTOLO MART, “to Paul, Apostle and Martyr,” pierced with holes through which the faithful once let down cloths to touch the tomb, and beneath it a great stone sarcophagus that had never been opened. On 28 June 2009, at the close of the Pauline Year, Pope Benedict XVI announced that a probe passed into the sarcophagus had found fragments of bone, grains of incense, and linen of purple and gold, and that the bone had been dated by carbon analysis to the first or second century. That the sarcophagus is the one venerated as Paul’s since Constantine is Tier 1. That the remains are the Apostle’s is Tier 2, and is held, as the Pope said, to agree with the unanimous and uncontested tradition.
In both basilicas, then, the spades of the twentieth century confirmed what Gaius said around the year 200. The altars stand where the trophies stood, and the trophies stood over the graves.
VIII. One feast for two apostles
Never separated. Rome has always kept Peter and Paul together. Their great feast falls on one day, 29 June, and the next day, the commemoration of St. Paul, still belongs to both. Their images guard the steps of St. Peter’s, and their statues stand together on the column-tops of the old city. St. Augustine told his people that the two apostles suffered on one day, and that even if they had suffered on different days they would still have been one, because they were one in faith and one in charity (Sermo 295.7). St. Leo the Great called them the two eyes of the body whose head is Christ, and said Rome had been refounded on them as the old city had been founded on Romulus and Remus (Sermo 82). The Fisherman and the Pharisee, the Apostle of the circumcision and the Apostle of the Gentiles, the one who saw the risen Christ on the shore of Galilee and the one who saw Him on the road to Damascus: the Church will not honour the one without the other.
The feast of the dedications. The anniversary of both dedications was first kept in Rome, as the anniversary of any great church is kept in its own city. In time it was extended to the whole Latin Church, so that every Catholic of the Roman rite, wherever he is, keeps the birthday of the two churches built over the founders of the Roman See. In the 1962 Missal the feast is of the third class. The Mass is the Mass for the dedication of a church, Terribilis est locus iste, with the Gloria and white vestments, as on the feast of the Lateran: the Introit of Jacob at Bethel, the Epistle of the new Jerusalem coming down out of heaven (Apoc. 21:2-5), and the Gospel of Zacchæus (Luke 19:1-10). The companion reflection for today shows how the same readings, heard over the graves of a forgiven fisherman and a converted persecutor, take on a new sense.
The November cycle is complete with today’s feast. On the ninth the Church honours the church of Peter’s chair, today the churches of the apostles’ tombs, and on the fifth of August the church of the Mother of God, St. Mary Major. The four major basilicas of Rome are kept in the calendar of the whole Church.
IX. Altars over the martyrs
Why the Church builds on graves. In the pagan city, the dead were kept outside the walls. A grave was a place of pollution, and no temple stood on one. The Christians did the opposite. They built their churches in cemeteries and set their altars on the bones of the martyrs. St. John had seen the reason in vision: “I saw under the altar the souls of them that were slain for the word of God, and for the testimony which they held” (Apoc. 6:9). The martyr is joined to the sacrifice of Christ. It was fitting that the Sacrifice of the altar should be offered over those who had offered themselves.
St. Jerome made the point against the priest Vigilantius, who mocked the veneration of relics as idolatry. Does the bishop of Rome do wrong, Jerome asked, when he offers sacrifice to the Lord over the bones of Peter and Paul, dead men in your eyes, but in ours venerable, and holds their tombs to be altars of Christ? Then not only the bishop of one city but the bishops of the whole world are wrong (Contra Vigilantium 8). St. Thomas teaches that the Church rightly honours the relics of the saints, because their bodies were the temples and instruments of the Holy Ghost dwelling and working in them, and are destined to be conformed to the glorious body of Christ at the resurrection (Summa Theologiæ III, q. 25, a. 6). The Council of Trent taught the same, and bound all who have the care of souls to teach it (Session XXV, De invocatione, veneratione et reliquiis sanctorum; Denzinger 1822).
This is why the traditional rite of consecration, described in the entry for the Lateran, seals relics of the martyrs in every altar stone. Every consecrated altar in the world is a small copy of the altars of the Vatican and the Ostian Way.
Why the Church builds on these graves. St. Paul told the Ephesians that the household of God is “built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone” (Eph. 2:20), and St. John saw the twelve names of the apostles written on the foundations of the heavenly city (Apoc. 21:14). The apostles are foundations because the Church rests on their witness, and Peter is the rock because Christ made him so. In Rome these words have a plain, physical sense. The two greatest churches of the city literally rest on the two apostles. The faith of the Roman Church is not an idea that drifted there. It came in the persons of two men, who taught it, were killed for it, and were buried in that soil. When the Church calls Rome the Apostolic See, she means first of all these graves.
X. East and West
Peter and Paul belong to the undivided Church, and the Christian East honours them as fully as the West. The Byzantine calendar keeps their feast on 29 June, with a fast before it, and on the next day the Synaxis of the Twelve Apostles. Eastern pilgrims came to the Roman tombs for centuries, and the Orthodox venerate them still.
The difference appears in what the two halves of Christendom made of the graves. When Constantine founded his new capital on the Bosphorus, he built there a church of the Holy Apostles to be his own tomb, and his son Constantius had relics of St. Andrew, St. Luke and St. Timothy brought to it in 356 and 357. New Rome had to gather apostles from elsewhere. Old Rome already had the two greatest, in her own earth. The East came to see Constantinople’s dignity as resting on its being the imperial city; Rome always rested her claim on Peter. The Church of Rome never argued that she was first because she was the capital. She argued that she was first because Peter was there, and because his successors are still there.
The deeper question of what Peter’s primacy means, a primacy of jurisdiction as the Vatican Council defined, or a primacy of honour as the Orthodox hold, is treated in the entry for the Lateran. Today’s feast adds only the ground on which the question stands: an Eastern Christian and a Latin Christian, kneeling at the Confessio of St. Peter, kneel at the same grave.
XI. What the day teaches
That the faith is historical. Christianity is not a set of ideas. It was carried by real men to a real city, and they died there on known roads and were buried in graves that can still be visited. The faith rests on witnesses, and the word martyr means witness.
That the Church keeps what is given her. For nineteen centuries, through persecutions, sacks, fires and rebuildings, the Roman Church has kept the graves of her founders and kept saying where they were. When the excavators finally dug, the graves were where she said.
That God builds on sinners. The two foundation stones of the Roman Church were a man who denied his Lord three times and a man who persecuted His Church. Both were forgiven, both were made new, and both gave their lives. No one should think himself too low to be built into the house of God.
That the end of the story is the resurrection. These churches are tombs, and a tomb is a place of waiting. St. John Chrysostom said that Rome’s true glory was not her gold and columns but that from her, on the last day, Peter and Paul will rise to meet the Lord (Homiliæ in Epistulam ad Romanos 32). Every Christian grave is a small Vatican hill.
Practice
Examine. Do I hold the faith as the apostles taught it, or as I would prefer it to be? Do I know the Creed as the faith for which Peter and Paul died? Have I, like Peter at the gate, ever fled from a duty that God was asking me to meet? Do I pray for the Pope, the successor of Peter, by name? Do I honour the relics of the saints, and do I treat the altar of my parish church as what it is, the place where the Sacrifice of Christ is offered over the bones of the martyrs? Do I remember that my own body, consecrated at baptism, will one day lie in a grave, waiting for the same resurrection?
Do. Learn whether the altar of your parish church is consecrated, and whose relics it holds; pray to that saint by name. Visit a cemetery this week, in this month of the holy souls, and pray at a Christian grave. If you cannot go to Rome, make a spiritual pilgrimage: in the morning say a Credo at the tomb of St. Peter, and in the evening a Credo at the tomb of St. Paul. Read the Second Epistle of St. Paul to Timothy, his last letter, and the First Epistle of St. Peter, written from Rome, which he calls Babylon (1 Pet. 5:13).
Pray. The Collect of the day:
Deus, qui nobis per singulos annos huius sancti templi tui consecrationis reparas diem, et sacris semper mysteriis repræsentas incolumes: exaudi preces populi tui, et præsta; ut, quisquis hoc templum beneficia petiturus ingreditur, cuncta se impetrasse lætetur. Per Dominum nostrum Iesum Christum Filium tuum, qui tecum vivit et regnat in unitate Spiritus Sancti Deus, per omnia sæcula sæculorum.
“O God, who year by year renewest for us the day of the consecration of this Thy holy temple, and ever bringest us safe to Thy sacred mysteries: hear the prayers of Thy people, and grant that whosoever enters this temple to ask for blessings may rejoice in having obtained all that he asked. Through our Lord Jesus Christ Thy Son, who liveth and reigneth with Thee in the unity of the Holy Ghost, God, world without end.”
Aspiration. In omnem terram exivit sonus eorum, et in fines orbis terræ verba eorum. “Their sound hath gone forth into all the earth: and their words unto the ends of the world” (Ps. 18:5).
Devote. Ask St. Peter for the grace to return to your duty when you have run from it, and St. Paul for the grace to spend yourself for Christ to the end. Ask St. Odo of Cluny, commemorated in the Martyrology today, to renew the monasteries and the clergy of the Church as he renewed St. Paul’s. Pray for the faithful departed who lie in the cemeteries around the two basilicas, and for all who wait in Christian graves for the resurrection.
If you wish to go deeper: the Church History path follows the apostolic tombs from the witness of Clement, Ignatius and Gaius through the memorial on the Appian Way, the Constantinian and Theodosian basilicas, the Saracen raid of 846, the rebuilding of St. Peter’s and the crisis of 1517, the fire of 1823, and the excavations of 1939-1949 and 2002-2006. The Sacred Liturgy path studies the Mass Terribilis, the November cycle of dedication feasts, and the placing of relics in the altar stone. The Theology and Doctrine path takes up the veneration of relics in St. Thomas and the Council of Trent, and the apostles as foundations of the Church. The East-West thread compares the apostolic claims of Old and New Rome and the church of the Holy Apostles at Constantinople. The Lives of the Saints path continues with the Chair of St. Peter (18 January), the Conversion of St. Paul (25 January), St. Peter’s Chains (1 August), and the feast of the apostles on 29 June.
Terribilis est locus iste: hic domus Dei est, et porta cæli.
Sources consulted: the Holy Scriptures in the Douay-Rheims version with the Vulgate; St. Clement of Rome, Epistula ad Corinthios 5-6; St. Ignatius of Antioch, Ad Romanos 4.3; Dionysius of Corinth and the priest Gaius, in Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica II.25.7-8; Origen, in Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica III.1.2; St. Irenæus, Adversus Hæreses III.3.2; Tertullian, De præscriptione hæreticorum 36; Tacitus, Annales XV.44; the Chronograph of 354, Depositio martyrum*; St. Damasus, epigram at the memorial on the Appian Way; St. Ambrose,* Sermo contra Auxentium 13 and the hymn Apostolorum passio*; St. Jerome,* Contra Vigilantium 8; St. Augustine, Sermo 295; St. Leo the Great, Sermo 82; St. John Chrysostom, Homiliæ in Epistulam ad Romanos 32; the Collectio Avellana 3; the Liber Pontificalis*, life of St. Sylvester; St. Thomas Aquinas,* Summa Theologiæ III, q. 25, a. 6; the Council of Trent, Sessions XXI and XXV; the Roman Breviary, lessons for 18 November; the Roman Martyrology; Pius XII, Christmas radio message of 1950; Paul VI, address of 26 June 1968; Benedict XVI, homily of 28 June 2009; the Catholic Encyclopedia (1907-1912), s.vv. “St. Peter’s,” “St. Paul Outside the Walls,” and “Relics”; Butler’s Lives of the Saints*. The Fathers are given in paraphrase. The dedication by St. Sylvester on 18 November is given as Roman tradition; the twelve baskets, the three fountains and the* Quo vadis are given as pious tradition; the identification of the bones beneath both altars is given as reliably reported but not certain.