Around the year 200, a Roman priest named Gaius was arguing with a heretic from Asia Minor who boasted that his province held the tombs of the apostles. Gaius answered him with a challenge that Eusebius preserved: come to Rome, and I will show you the trophies of the apostles. Go to the Vatican, or go out along the road to Ostia, and you will find the trophies of those who founded this Church (Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica II.25.7). By “trophies” Gaius meant the monuments over their graves, the victory-markers of men who had conquered by dying. Peter lay on the Vatican hill, beside the circus of Nero where he was crucified. Paul lay two miles south of the walls, near the place on the Ostian Way where he was beheaded.
A little more than a century later the Emperor Constantine raised a basilica over each trophy. The Roman Breviary records the tradition that Pope St. Sylvester dedicated both of them on this day. The buildings have changed since. Constantine’s St. Peter’s, after twelve hundred years, was pulled down and rebuilt, and the new basilica was consecrated by Urban VIII on the eighteenth of November 1626, the anniversary of the first. St. Paul’s outside the Walls was enlarged under the emperors of the late fourth century, burned almost to the ground in 1823, and rebuilt by the gifts of the whole Catholic world; Pius IX consecrated it in 1854. But the trophies have not moved. Under the high altar of each basilica the apostle still lies where Gaius pointed. When Pius XII announced to the world in 1950 that the excavations beneath St. Peter’s had found the tomb of the Prince of the Apostles, he was confirming what the Roman Church had always said.
Nine days ago the Church kept the dedication of the Lateran, the Pope’s cathedral and the mother of all churches. Today she keeps the dedication of the two churches built over the men on whom the Roman Church was founded. The Mass is the same, Terribilis, from the Common of the Dedication of a Church, with Gloria, white vestments, and no commemoration. The Epistle and Gospel are the same too. But the Church does not repeat herself idly. The same readings, heard over the graves of Peter and Paul, say something new.
St. Leo the Great said it best, preaching on the apostles’ feast. Rome, he said, owed her first founding to two brothers, Romulus and Remus, one of whom killed the other. God gave her a second founding through two other men, Peter and Paul, who made her a holy nation, a chosen people, a priestly and royal city, and the head of the world by religion more widely than she had ever ruled by arms (Sermo 82.1). The city of the Epistle comes down out of heaven. But in Rome it came down onto two graves.
I. Vidi sanctam civitatem: the Epistle
“In those days: I John saw the holy city, the new Jerusalem, coming down out of heaven from God, prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. And I heard a great voice from the throne, saying: Behold the tabernacle of God with men, and he will dwell with them. And they shall be his people; and God himself with them shall be their God. And God shall wipe away all tears from their eyes: and death shall be no more, nor mourning, nor crying, nor sorrow shall be any more, for the former things are passed away. And he that sat on the throne, said: Behold, I make all things new.” (Apoc. 21:2-5)
The city has foundations. The Missal’s lesson ends at the fifth verse, but St. John’s vision goes on, and a few lines later he describes the walls of the city: “And the wall of the city had twelve foundations, and in them, the twelve names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb” (Apoc. 21:14). This is the key to today’s feast. The heavenly city is not built on nothing. It rests on the apostles, as St. Paul told the Ephesians: “you are fellow citizens with the saints, and the domestics of God, built upon the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Jesus Christ himself being the chief corner stone” (Eph. 2:19-20). The Venerable Bede, commenting on the Apocalypse, explains that the apostles are called foundations because the whole Church was built on their preaching, and that their names are written in the foundation because their faith and teaching bear up everything that rests on them (Explanatio Apocalypsis III, on 21:14). Christ is the one foundation, as Paul insists elsewhere (1 Cor. 3:11). The apostles are foundations in Him and because of Him.
So when the Church dedicates a basilica over the tomb of an apostle, she is doing in stone what St. John saw in vision. She is laying the name of an apostle at the foundation of a house of God. The altar of St. Peter’s stands over Peter; the altar of St. Paul’s stands over Paul. Everything above them, the dome, the nave, the crowds of pilgrims, rests on them, as the whole visible Church rests on the faith they preached.
Coming down out of heaven from God. The city comes down. This guards against a mistake. One could look at St. Peter’s, the largest church in Christendom, and think the Church is the greatest thing men have built. The Epistle says the opposite. The city is not raised by men; it is sent by God. Peter did not make himself a rock. “Blessed art thou, Simon Bar-Jona: because flesh and blood hath not revealed it to thee, but my Father who is in heaven” (Matt. 16:17). Paul did not make himself an apostle. He was “an apostle, not of men, neither by man, but by Jesus Christ, and God the Father” (Gal. 1:1). The foundations themselves came down from heaven before the city did.
Prepared as a bride adorned for her husband. St. John Chrysostom, preaching at Antioch on the Epistle to the Romans, broke off from his exposition to speak of Rome itself. He said he loved that city, not for its gold, its columns, or its pomp, but because it held the bodies of these two pillars of the Church. Heaven itself, he said, is not as bright with the sun as Rome is with these two lights spread over the whole world. And then he looked forward to the end. From Rome, he said, Paul will be caught up on the last day, and Peter too, to meet the Lord in the air. Think what a sight Rome will see, what a rose she will send up to Christ, what crowns she will wear (Homiliæ in Epistulam ad Romanos 32). Chrysostom’s Rome is the bride of the Epistle seen in advance. Her adornment is not her marble. It is the bodies of the saints she guards for the resurrection.
Death shall be no more. These basilicas are built over graves. That is their whole reason for existing. In the pagan city, tombs were kept outside the walls, and the dead were a source of pollution. The Christians did the unthinkable: they built their churches on cemeteries and set their altars on the bones of the dead. They did so because of this verse. The apostles’ tombs are not monuments to death but to its defeat. Peter and Paul are not finished; they are waiting. The voice from the throne has promised that “the former things are passed away,” and the Church places her altars over her martyrs as a public declaration that she believes it.
Behold, I make all things new. Of whom could this be said more plainly than of these two men? Simon the fisherman of Bethsaida became Peter, the rock. Saul of Tarsus, who held the cloaks while Stephen was stoned, became Paul, the Apostle of the Gentiles. God did not merely improve them. He made them new. And He did it, in both cases, by first finding them as sinners.
II. Hodie huic domui salus facta est: the Gospel
“At that time: Jesus entering in, walked through Jericho. And behold, there was a man named Zacheus, who was the chief of the publicans, and he was rich. And he sought to see Jesus who he was, and he could not for the crowd, because he was low of stature. And running before, he climbed up into a sycamore tree, that he might see him; for he was to pass that way. And when Jesus was come to the place, looking up, he saw him, and said to him: Zacheus, make haste and come down; for this day I must abide in thy house. And he made haste and came down; and received him with joy. And when all saw it, they all murmured, saying, that he was gone to be a guest with a man that was a sinner. But Zacheus standing, said to the Lord: Behold, Lord, the half of my goods I give to the poor; and if I have wronged any man of any thing, I restore him fourfold. Jesus said to him: This day is salvation come to this house; because he also is a son of Abraham. For the Son of man is come to seek and to save that which was lost.” (Luke 19:1-10)
The Church reads the story of Zacchaeus at every dedication, because it turns on a house that Christ enters. Heard on the feast of the Lateran, it speaks of the Church as the house of God. Heard on the feast of Peter and Paul, it speaks of the apostles themselves. For the two men whose tombs we honour today were, each in his own way, a Zacchaeus.
The chief of the publicans. Zacchaeus was princeps publicanorum, the chief of the tax collectors, the first among sinners in Jericho. St. Paul uses almost the same title of himself. “A faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into this world to save sinners, of whom I am the chief” (1 Tim. 1:15). In the Vulgate the word is primus, the first. And Paul goes on, in words that sound like the last line of today’s Gospel: “But for this cause have I obtained mercy: that in me first Christ Jesus might shew forth all patience, for the information of them that shall believe in him unto life everlasting” (1 Tim. 1:16). The Son of Man came to seek and to save that which was lost, and the persecutor of the Church was the proof of it. Paul is the chief of sinners as Zacchaeus was the chief of publicans, and both of them became the evidence of what mercy can do.
He was low of stature. St. Augustine noticed something about Paul’s name. Saul was the name of the tall king of Israel, head and shoulders above the people (1 Kings 9:2). Paulus, in Latin, means small, little. Augustine says the Apostle took this name, or was content to bear it, to show himself a little one, the least of the apostles, as he calls himself, “not worthy to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God” (1 Cor. 15:9; Augustine, De spiritu et littera VII.12). The tall Saul became the little Paul. Zacchaeus was small in body; Paul made himself small in spirit. Both had to come down before Christ could lift them up. Augustine draws the lesson for everyone: grace is given to the humble, and the man who wishes to be great in the Kingdom must first consent to be small.
He could not for the crowd. St. Cyril of Alexandria, preaching on this Gospel, observes that the crowd stands in the way of everyone who wants to see Christ, and that Zacchaeus overcame it not by pushing through but by rising above it (Commentarius in Lucam, on 19:1-10). Peter knew that crowd. In the courtyard of the high priest, the opinion of a servant girl and a few men by the fire was enough to make him deny that he had ever known the Lord. Human respect is the crowd that blocks the view of Christ. Peter was blocked by it once. Afterward he stood before the Sanhedrin and said, “We ought to obey God, rather than men” (Acts 5:29). The man who could not face a servant girl faced the council, then Herod’s prison, and at last Nero.
Looking up, he saw him. Zacchaeus climbed to see Jesus, but Jesus saw him first, and called him by name. This is how both apostles were called. Peter was mending nets when Christ looked at him and said, “Come after me.” After the great catch of fish, Peter fell at His knees and said, “Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord” (Luke 5:8). He felt what Zacchaeus felt, and the Lord did not depart; He made him a fisher of men. Paul was riding to Damascus, breathing threats against the disciples, when a light from heaven struck him down and a voice called him by name: “Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?” (Acts 9:4). Neither went looking for an apostleship. In both cases, as with Zacchaeus, the Seeker was Christ.
There is a further detail. St. Luke notes that after the denial, “the Lord turning looked on Peter. And Peter remembered the word of the Lord… And Peter going out, wept bitterly” (Luke 22:61-62). It is the same gaze that rested on Zacchaeus in the tree. St. Ambrose, commenting on Peter’s tears, writes that he reads of Peter’s weeping but not of any words of excuse. Tears, he says, wash away a sin that the voice is ashamed to confess, and they ask pardon without speaking (Expositio Evangelii secundum Lucam X.88-90). Christ’s look did for Peter what it did for Zacchaeus: it called him down from his self-defence into repentance.
I restore him fourfold. Zacchaeus did not stop at sorrow. He repaired what he had done. Half his goods went to the poor, and every man he had cheated got back four times what he lost. Both apostles made the same kind of restitution. Peter had denied his Lord three times; by the Sea of Tiberias the risen Christ asked him three times, “Lovest thou me?”, and three times Peter answered. St. Augustine comments that the threefold confession of love was given to answer the threefold denial, so that his tongue might serve love as much as it had served fear (In Iohannis Evangelium Tractatus 123.5). Paul, who had laid waste the Church, spent the rest of his life building it up: “I have laboured more abundantly than all they: yet not I, but the grace of God with me” (1 Cor. 15:10). He had dragged Christians to prison; he would spend years in prison for Christ. He had consented to Stephen’s death; he would give his own neck to the sword. That is fourfold restitution.
This day I must abide in thy house. Here is the deepest meaning of today’s feast. Christ entered the house of Zacchaeus, and salvation came to it. Christ entered the lives of Peter and Paul, and they became His house: Peter the rock on which He built His Church, Paul the “vessel of election, to carry my name before the Gentiles” (Acts 9:15). And when they died, the Church built houses for Christ over their bodies. The basilicas of the Vatican and the Ostian Way are the house of Zacchaeus on a grand scale. In each of them, every day, Christ comes down on an altar raised over a forgiven sinner, and says again, “This day I must abide in thy house.”
He also is a son of Abraham. The crowd had written Zacchaeus out of Israel. Christ wrote him back in. Paul, who had been “a Hebrew of the Hebrews” (Phil. 3:5), learned on the road to Damascus that the true children of Abraham are those who share Abraham’s faith, and he spent his life bringing the Gentiles into that family (Gal. 3:7-9). Peter learned the same lesson in the house of the centurion Cornelius, when he saw the Holy Ghost fall on the uncircumcised (Acts 10). The two apostles opened the house of Abraham to the nations. Rome, the capital of the Gentiles, became through them the city where the sons of Abraham are counted from every people under heaven.
III. The Mass as a whole: the city comes down onto the graves of sinners
St. Thomas built the Summa Theologiæ on the great movement of all things out from God and back to Him, exitus and reditus (I, q. 2, prologue). Today’s Mass shows that movement passing through two human lives.
The Epistle is the exitus. Everything comes from above. The city comes down from heaven; the voice comes from the throne; God Himself pitches His tent among men. Even the foundations of the city, the apostles, are God’s gift and not men’s achievement.
The Gospel shows how God’s coming-down reaches those it is meant for. Christ walks into Jericho, looks up into a tree, and calls a sinner by name. He does not wait for Zacchaeus to deserve Him. He enters first, and then the sinner’s house is turned inside out: wealth goes to the poor, injustice is repaired, a lost son is restored to Abraham. This is the reditus, the return of the creature to God, and it begins with God’s own coming.
Peter and Paul are where these two movements meet in history. God came down to a fisherman and a persecutor. They were turned back to Him, and in turning they became the foundations of the city that comes down. Their lives ended in Rome, in the supreme act of return, a death offered for Christ. St. Augustine, preaching on their feast, reminded his people that the two apostles suffered on one day, and that they were one, though they suffered on different days, because they were one in faith and one in charity (Sermo 295.7). The Church has never separated them since. Over their graves she built two houses of God, and the city of the Epistle now has, in Rome, two places where it touches the earth.
The poet Prudentius, visiting Rome about the year 400, described the scene on the apostles’ feast. The Tiber, he wrote, divides the two holy tombs, one on each bank. The whole people of Rome pours through the streets, crossing back and forth between the two basilicas, hurrying to honour both apostles on the same day (Peristephanon XII). That crowd of pilgrims, moving between the graves of two forgiven sinners, is a picture of the Church: a people that has been sought and saved, going up to the house of God.
And every Mass we hear completes the meeting. At the consecration the tabernacle of God is truly with men. At Communion the Lord says to each of us what He said to Zacchaeus and, in their turn, to Peter and to Paul: Hodie in domo tua oportet me manere. If we receive Him with joy and make restitution for our sins, salvation comes to the house of our soul, and our soul is built, a living stone, onto the foundation of the apostles.
IV. The Collect
Deus, qui nobis per singulos annos huius sancti templi tui consecrationis reparas diem, et sacris semper mysteriis repræsentas incolumes: exaudi preces populi tui, et præsta; ut, quisquis hoc templum beneficia petiturus ingreditur, cuncta se impetrasse lætetur.
“O God, who year by year renewest for us the day of the consecration of this Thy holy temple, and ever bringest us safe to Thy sacred mysteries: hear the prayers of Thy people, and grant that whosoever enters this temple to ask for blessings may rejoice in having obtained all that he asked.”
The prayer was composed for a church celebrating its own anniversary, and when it is said today in a parish far from Rome, the “temple” it speaks of is the Church built on the apostles. Two words in it fit today’s feast closely. Repræsentas incolumes: God brings us back safe, unharmed, to His mysteries, year after year. Peter and Paul both knew what it was to be brought back. Peter was brought back from his denial and from Herod’s prison; Paul from shipwreck, from stoning, from the brink of death more than once. And quisquis: whoever enters. Not only the worthy. The temple that stands over the chief of sinners is open to every sinner, and the Church dares to ask that every one of them may go home, like Zacchaeus, having received everything.
V. A word for practice
Examine. Have I let the crowd, the opinions of the people around me, keep me from Christ, as it kept Peter by the fire in the courtyard? Is there a sin I have regretted but never repaired? Do I confess my faults as Peter did, with tears and without excuses, or do I explain them away? Do I think of myself as the chief of sinners, or as someone who does not really need mercy? Am I loyal to the faith of the apostles, which the Roman Church has kept since Peter and Paul died for it? Do I pray for the Pope, the successor of Peter?
Do. Make one act of restitution this week, however small: return something, pay something, repair a reputation you have damaged, or give to the poor in proportion to what you have kept for yourself. Make a good confession if it has been some time. Pray the Creed slowly, remembering that it is the faith of the apostles, on which the Church is built. If you cannot go to Rome, make a spiritual pilgrimage: picture the two basilicas on either side of the Tiber, and pray at each of the two tombs in turn. Pray for the faithful departed, especially in this month of the holy souls, that the God who wipes away every tear will bring them soon to the city where death is no more.
Pray. The Collect of the day. Then St. Peter’s prayer in the boat, “Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord,” followed by St. Paul’s answer to it: “By the grace of God, I am what I am; and his grace in me hath not been void” (1 Cor. 15:10).
Aspiration. Venit Filius hominis quærere et salvum facere quod perierat. “The Son of man is come to seek and to save that which was lost.”
Devote. On this Wednesday, a day traditionally given to St. Joseph, ask the Patron of the Universal Church to guard the Church of Peter and Paul as he guarded the Holy Family. Ask St. Peter for the grace of true sorrow, and St. Paul for the grace to labour for Christ as hard as you once laboured for yourself. Ask Our Lady, Queen of Apostles, to keep you on the foundation they laid.
If you wish to go deeper: the Church History path tells the story of the apostles’ tombs: the testimony of Gaius, the Constantinian basilicas, the fire of 1823 and the rebuilding of St. Paul’s, the consecration of the new St. Peter’s in 1626, and the excavations under the Vatican. The Theology and Doctrine path examines the apostles as foundations of the Church, the primacy of Peter and his successors, and the Church as the city of God. The Lives of the Saints path follows the call, fall, and restoration of St. Peter, and the conversion and labours of St. Paul. The Sacred Liturgy path explains the Mass Terribilis, the meaning of altars built over relics, and the place of the dedication feasts of November in the Church’s year.
Sources. Scripture is cited from the Douay-Rheims, with the Vulgate. The Fathers are given in paraphrase with their loci: Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica II.25.7 (Gaius); St. Leo the Great, Sermo 82.1; St. John Chrysostom, Homiliæ in Epistulam ad Romanos 32; St. Bede the Venerable, Explanatio Apocalypsis III (on 21:14); St. Cyril of Alexandria, Commentarius in Lucam (on 19:1-10); St. Augustine, De spiritu et littera VII.12, In Iohannis Evangelium Tractatus 123.5, and Sermo 295.7; St. Ambrose, Expositio Evangelii secundum Lucam X.88-90; Prudentius, Peristephanon XII. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue. The history of the basilicas and the tradition of their dedication by St. Sylvester follow the Roman Breviary lessons for 18 November and the traditional accounts.
Terribilis est locus iste: hic domus Dei est, et porta cæli.