Skip to content

The Oil That Is Not for Sale

A reflection for the Feast of St. Gertrude, Virgin — S. Gertrudis Virginis, III classis (16 November), Feria II infra Hebdomadam VI quæ superfuit post Epiphaniam

In the monastery of Helfta, in Saxony, on a winter evening in January of 1281, a nun of twenty-five was standing in the dormitory after Compline. She had been in the cloister since she was a child of five. She was learned, more learned than most men of her day: she read Latin with ease, loved the liberal arts, and had given herself to her books with an eagerness she later judged to be a kind of vanity. For a month she had been troubled by a heaviness of heart she could not explain. And that evening, as she bowed her head, she saw standing before her a youth of great beauty, about sixteen years old, who spoke to her with gentleness: Your salvation will come quickly. Why are you consumed with grief? He held out His hand to her, and she understood whose hand it was.

This is how St. Gertrude tells the beginning of her conversion in the second book of the Legatus divinæ pietatis, the Herald of Divine Love, the one part of that great book she wrote with her own hand (Legatus II.1). She did not mean that she had been a bad nun. She meant that until that night she had glorified herself, in her learning and her gifts, and that from that night she began to glory only in the Lord. She lived another twenty years or so, and died at Helfta around 1301 or 1302, never having left the enclosure, never having held any office of note. The Church calls her the Great, the only woman so named among the saints of the Latin calendar.

She was never canonized by formal process. Her cult grew from her writings and from the devotion of the monasteries that read them; her name was entered in the Roman Martyrology in 1677, and Clement XII extended her feast to the universal Church in 1738. For centuries she was confused with her own abbess, Gertrude of Hackeborn, and painted with an abbess’s crozier she never carried. The Church has kept her feast all the same, because the Church knows her by what she wrote, and what she wrote is one long confession that God alone is worth glorying in.

The Mass is from the Common of a Virgin, Dilexisti, with a proper Collect, and the vestments are white. The Introit sings the bridal psalm: “Thou hast loved justice, and hated iniquity: therefore God, thy God, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness” (Ps. 44:8). The Offertory continues it: “The daughters of kings are in thy honour, the queen stood on thy right hand.” And the Communion takes up the Gospel: “The five wise virgins took oil in their vessels with their lamps; and at midnight there was a cry made: Behold the bridegroom cometh; go ye forth to meet Christ the Lord.” From the Introit to the Communion, the whole Mass is lit by a single image: oil. The oil with which God anoints the Bride, and the oil the wise virgins carried in their vessels.

It is Monday of the sixth week after the Epiphany, resumed in these last weeks of the year. Yesterday’s Gospel was the parable of the mustard seed and the leaven, the kingdom that grows unseen, hidden in the measures of meal until the whole is leavened. Gertrude’s life was a grain of that kind: buried in a Saxon cloister, invisible to the world, and growing in secret into something the whole Church would one day shelter under.

I. Qui gloriatur, in Domino glorietur: the Epistle

“Brethren: He that glorieth, let him glory in the Lord. For not he who commendeth himself, is approved, but he, whom God commendeth. Would to God you could bear with some little of my folly: but do bear with me. For I am jealous of you with the jealousy of God. For I have espoused you to one husband that I may present you as a chaste virgin to Christ.” (2 Cor. 10:17-18; 11:1-2)

He that glorieth, let him glory in the Lord. St. Paul is quoting the Prophet Jeremias: “Let not the wise man glory in his wisdom, and let not the strong man glory in his strength, and let not the rich man glory in his riches: but let him that glorieth glory in this, that he understandeth and knoweth me” (Jer. 9:23-24). The Apostle had used the same text before, to the same Corinthians, at the beginning of his first letter, against those who boasted of their teachers and their eloquence (1 Cor. 1:31). The Corinthians were a clever people, and they were dazzled by clever preachers. Paul answers them with the Prophet: the only glory that does not rot is the glory of knowing God.

No Father returned to this verse more often than St. Augustine, because it held for him the whole doctrine of grace. What hast thou that thou hast not received? And if thou hast received, why dost thou glory, as if thou hadst not received it? (1 Cor. 4:7). To glory in the Lord, Augustine teaches, is to confess that every good thing in us, even our good will and our good works, is His gift; and to glory in oneself is precisely the pride that makes the gift useless (De spiritu et littera 7.11; cf. De gratia et libero arbitrio 6.15). The point is not that we have no glory. It is that our glory has a source, and that the man who forgets the source turns the gift into a theft.

Not he who commendeth himself, is approved, but he whom God commendeth. The Greek word for approved, dokimos, is the word for a coin that has been tested and found true, or a metal that has passed through the fire. A man may stamp his own face on a coin, but that does not make it gold. St. John Chrysostom, preaching on this verse, says that Paul is setting two judgments side by side, the judgment we pass on ourselves and the judgment God passes on us, and that only the second will stand on the last day; self-praise is a counterfeit coin that will not pass at the gate (Homiliæ in epistulam II ad Corinthios 22). Ambrosiaster puts it simply: the man whose praise comes from himself has his whole reward already, and has nothing left to receive (Commentarius in epistulam II ad Corinthios, on 10:18).

Gertrude’s book is full of this verse, though she rarely quotes it. The nuns who wrote down the rest of the Legatus after her dictation remembered how she spoke of herself: that she counted herself the least and the most unworthy of all creatures, and marvelled that the earth would bear her up (Legatus I.11). This was not false modesty. A woman who had once been proud of her learning had come to see that her learning, her gifts, and above all the extraordinary favours God was showing her, were not hers at all. She glorified in them only as one glories in a gift from the beloved, by praising the one who gave it.

Would to God you could bear with some little of my folly. Paul is about to do something he finds distasteful: he is going to boast, in the chapters that follow, of his labours, his shipwrecks, his scourgings, and his visions, because the false apostles at Corinth have forced him to. He calls it folly in advance. But even here, he will glory in the Lord. The thing he boasts of last and most is his weakness: “Gladly therefore will I glory in my infirmities, that the power of Christ may dwell in me” (2 Cor. 12:9). The only boast a Christian can make without folly is the boast of what God has done in a weak vessel.

I am jealous of you with the jealousy of God. This is a lover’s jealousy, and Paul says plainly that it is not his own: it is God’s jealousy, Dei æmulatione, the jealousy of the God of Sinai who “is a jealous God” (Ex. 20:5) because He will not share His people with idols. St. John Chrysostom notes the strangeness of the image. Paul does not make himself the bridegroom; he makes himself the one who arranged the marriage, the friend who brought the bride to the bridegroom, as John the Baptist called himself “the friend of the bridegroom” (John 3:29). And a friend of that kind, says Chrysostom, is jealous not for himself but for the bridegroom, and fears for the bride only that she should be faithful to the one to whom he gave her (Homiliæ in epistulam II ad Corinthios 23).

I have espoused you to one husband that I may present you as a chaste virgin to Christ. Here the Epistle opens onto the mystery the Church celebrates today. Paul is speaking of the whole Church of Corinth, men and women alike, married and unmarried. The Church herself is the virgin; Christ is her one husband; and the day of presentation is the last day, when the Bridegroom comes. St. Augustine says that the whole Church is a virgin, because she keeps whole her faith, her hope, and her charity, and that this virginity of the heart belongs to every Christian (In Iohannis Evangelium tractatus 13.12; Sermo 93.4). Theodoret reads the verse the same way: Paul has betrothed the Church by preaching, and the marriage is consummated in the life to come (Interpretatio in epistulam II ad Corinthios, on 11:2).

But the Church has always read this verse, too, of those who make that virginity visible in the body. St. Ambrose, writing to his sister Marcellina, called the consecrated virgin the one in whom the Church sees most clearly what she herself is: a bride kept whole for Christ (De virginibus I.6.31). St. Jerome, writing to the young Eustochium, told her to let the secret of her chamber guard her, and the Bridegroom sport with her within (Epistula 22.25). The consecrated virgin is the Church’s living icon of herself. And Gertrude, whose third Spiritual Exercise is a long renewal of the rite of a virgin’s consecration, prayed over this mystery her whole life. She did not think of herself as having given something up. She thought of herself as having been espoused.

II. Ecce sponsus venit: the Gospel

“At that time, Jesus spoke to his disciples this parable: The kingdom of heaven shall be like to ten virgins, who taking their lamps went out to meet the bridegroom and the bride. And five of them were foolish, and five wise. But the five foolish, having taken their lamps, did not take oil with them: but the wise took oil in their vessels with the lamps. And the bridegroom tarrying, they all slumbered and slept. And at midnight there was a cry made: Behold the bridegroom cometh, go ye forth to meet him. Then all those virgins arose and trimmed their lamps. And the foolish said to the wise: Give us of your oil, for our lamps are gone out. The wise answered, saying: Lest perhaps there be not enough for us and for you, go ye rather to them that sell, and buy for yourselves. Now whilst they went to buy, the bridegroom came: and they that were ready, went in with him to the marriage, and the door was shut. But at last came also the other virgins, saying: Lord, Lord, open to us. But he answering said: Amen I say to you, I know you not. Watch ye therefore, because you know not the day nor the hour.” (Matt. 25:1-13)

Ten virgins. The parable stands among the last things Our Lord taught before His Passion, in the great discourse on the end of the world that fills the twenty-fourth and twenty-fifth chapters of St. Matthew. All ten are virgins. All ten carry lamps. All ten go out to meet the bridegroom, and all ten fall asleep. Nothing visible distinguishes the wise from the foolish until the cry at midnight. St. Gregory the Great, preaching on this Gospel to the people of Rome at the tomb of a virgin martyr, draws the lesson at once: the parable is not about those outside the Church, but about those within it. All of them have faith; all of them have the lamp of good works shining before men. The difference is hidden (Homiliæ in Evangelia 12.1-2).

The foolish took no oil. What, then, is the oil? Here the Fathers give two answers, and they belong together.

St. Gregory answers that the lamps are our good works, which shine outwardly, and the oil is the inward intention with which they are done: the glory we seek in the hidden place of conscience. The foolish virgins have lamps but no oil, because they do good to be seen and praised by men. Their works shine, but there is nothing inside them; and when the Judge comes, who looks only at the heart, their lamps go out. The wise carry oil in their vessels, in vasis suis, that is, in their hearts, where they seek the glory that comes from God alone (Homiliæ in Evangelia 12.3). Gregory sets beside this the very words of the Apostle: “Our glory is this, the testimony of our conscience” (2 Cor. 1:12).

St. Augustine answers that the oil is charity, which alone gives light to the works of faith and without which “I am become as sounding brass, or a tinkling cymbal” (1 Cor. 13:1). And he notices something in the parable that makes the two answers one. Why do the wise send the foolish to them that sell? Who are the sellers of oil? They are flatterers, says Augustine: those who sell praise. The foolish virgins have always bought their oil from men, from the praise and approval of others, and when the Bridegroom comes they run back to the only market they know. But there is no oil there that will burn before God. The sellers of praise can give only what they have, which is nothing (Sermo 93.8-11).

This is the hinge of today’s Mass. The Epistle and the Gospel are saying the same thing in two languages. Not he who commendeth himself is approved, but he whom God commendeth. The foolish virgins commended themselves, and bought commendation from others; their lamps were lit with borrowed glory. The wise gloried in the Lord, in the secret place of the heart, and their oil was His. St. John Chrysostom gives yet another reading, that the oil is mercy to the poor, and the sellers are the poor themselves, from whom we buy oil by almsgiving while there is still time (Homiliæ in Matthæum 78.1). It is the same oil seen from a third side: a charity that does not seek to be seen, given to those who cannot repay.

Give us of your oil. The answer of the wise sounds hard: Lest perhaps there be not enough for us and for you. But it is not selfishness. It is the truth about the oil. St. Hilary of Poitiers says that no one can be saved by another’s works, because each must carry the oil of his own vessel; the merits of the saints help us by their prayers, but they cannot be lent to fill a lamp that was left empty (Commentarius in Matthæum 27.5). St. Jerome adds that the refusal of the wise is not a want of charity but a want of time: the midnight has come, the market is closed, and what was not bought in this life cannot be bought in the next (Commentarius in Matthæum IV, on 25:9).

At midnight there was a cry made. St. Jerome records an ancient tradition, which he says came down from the Apostles: that Christ would come at midnight, as the angel of the Pasch came at midnight in Egypt, and that for this reason the people were not dismissed from the Easter Vigil before midnight, lest the Bridegroom should come and find them gone (Commentarius in Matthæum IV, on 25:6). Whether or not the Lord comes at that hour, the meaning is plain. The coming is sudden, and it is in the dark. St. Gregory says that the midnight is the hour when no one expects it, and that the cry is the trumpet of the last day; but he adds that each man’s own midnight is the hour of his death, which comes upon him as suddenly as the end of the world (Homiliæ in Evangelia 12.4).

They all slumbered and slept. The wise slept too. Our Lord does not blame them for it. St. Jerome and St. Hilary both read the sleep as death, which comes to the wise and the foolish alike (Jerome, Commentarius in Matthæum IV, on 25:5; Hilary, Commentarius in Matthæum 27.4). The difference is not that the wise stayed awake through the whole long night of the Bridegroom’s delay. It is that, when they lay down, their vessels were full.

The door was shut. I know you not. Here the parable becomes terrible. The foolish come back, calling Lord, Lord, the very words the Lord had warned would not suffice (Matt. 7:21), and they are answered, Nescio vos, I know you not. St. Augustine asks how the Lord who knows all things can say He does not know them, and answers that He does not know them with the knowledge of approval, as a man says of a stranger at his door, “I do not know him” (Sermo 93.15). They were never His, though they bore His lamps. And this returns us to the Epistle once more: not he who commendeth himself is approved. The ones the Bridegroom does not know are the ones who were always seeking to be known by someone else.

III. The Mass as a whole: the Bride goes out, and is brought in

St. Thomas built the Summa Theologiæ on the great circle of exitus and reditus: all things come forth from God, and all things return to Him through Christ, who as man is our way to God (Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue). Today’s Mass traces that circle as a wedding procession.

The going-forth begins with God’s own love. “Thou hast loved justice,” sings the Introit, “therefore God, thy God, hath anointed thee.” The Bridegroom comes forth first: from the Father, into our flesh, to seek a Bride He will make beautiful by His own anointing. The oil of gladness is His before it is ever hers. And then the Bride goes out to meet Him: “They went out to meet the bridegroom.” Paul goes out preaching, and betroths a Church at Corinth; a little girl of five is given to the monastery at Helfta; the virgins take their lamps and go out into the night. All of this is the exitus of the soul, sent forth into time to wait.

The return is the entry into the marriage. “They that were ready went in with him to the marriage.” It is the moment Paul longed for when he spoke of presenting the Corinthians as a chaste virgin to Christ: the presentation of the Bride at the wedding feast of the Lamb (Apoc. 19:7-9). And the only thing that carries the soul through the door is the oil, which is to say, the grace of God received in the heart and kept burning by charity. The lamps of our works will not light themselves. The oil cannot be bought at the end. It must be received, and kept, and carried, through the whole night of waiting.

This is why the Epistle insists that we glory only in the Lord. The oil is not ours. Every drop of it is His gift, and the soul that glories in itself has, by that very act, poured the oil out. The circle of exitus and reditus is closed only by grace: we go out because He calls, and we come back because He carries us. The wise virgins are wise only because they know that.

St. Gertrude knew it to the depths of her soul. In the fourth book of the Legatus her sisters set down a vision she had on the feast of St. John the Evangelist, in which the beloved disciple let her rest with him upon the breast of the Lord, and she heard the beating of the Divine Heart. She asked him why he, who had rested there at the Last Supper, had written nothing of it in his Gospel. He answered that his task had been to speak of the Word to the infant Church, and that the sweetness of those heartbeats had been reserved for the last times, so that a world grown old and cold in the love of God might be warmed again by hearing them (Legatus IV.4). Four centuries before Paray-le-Monial, a cloistered virgin in Saxony was already listening at that Heart. It was the source of her oil. And when she was dying, the tradition remembers, she longed for the coming of the Bridegroom as a bride longs for her wedding.

IV. The Collects

Deus, qui in corde beatæ Gertrudis Virginis iucundam tibi mansionem præparasti: ipsius meritis et intercessione, cordis nostri maculas clementer absterge, et eiusdem tribue gaudere consortio.

“O God, who in the heart of blessed Gertrude the Virgin didst prepare for Thyself a pleasant dwelling: by her merits and intercession, mercifully wash away the stains of our heart, and grant us to rejoice in her company.”

The Collect is all about the heart. It does not praise Gertrude’s learning, her writings, or her visions. It says only that God made her heart a dwelling He found pleasant, iucundam mansionem, and that He prepared it Himself. This is the Epistle in a sentence: the glory is God’s, the work is God’s, and Gertrude’s part was to let Him build. The word mansio recalls the promise of the Last Supper: “If any one love me, he will keep my word, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him, and will make our abode with him” (John 14:23), mansionem apud eum faciemus.

The petition is humble and exact. We do not ask to receive Gertrude’s graces. We ask that the stains of our heart be washed away, because a heart that is stained is a lamp whose vessel leaks. And we ask to rejoice in her consortium, her company, which is the company of the wise virgins who went in to the marriage.

Accepta tibi sit, Domine, sacratæ plebis oblatio pro tuorum honore Sanctorum: quorum se meritis de tribulatione percepisse cognoscit auxilium.

“May the offering of Thy consecrated people be acceptable to Thee, O Lord, in honour of Thy Saints: by whose merits it acknowledges that it has received help in tribulation.”

The Secret calls the Church sacrata plebs, a consecrated people. The whole people of God is consecrated, as the whole Church of Corinth was espoused; the virgin at the altar only shows it forth.

Satiasti, Domine, familiam tuam muneribus sacris: eius, quæsumus, semper interventione nos refove, cuius solemnia celebramus.

“Thou hast filled Thy household, O Lord, with sacred gifts: ever refresh us, we beseech Thee, by the intercession of her whose feast we celebrate.”

The Postcommunion gives thanks that God has filled, satiasti, His household. The vessels have been filled at the altar. The Eucharist is the oil of the wise virgins; it is what we carry out into the night.

V. A word for practice

Examine. Where do I buy my oil? Do I do the good I do in order to be seen, thanked, or admired, and do I feel the loss when no one notices? Do I commend myself, in conversation, in my work, in the quiet story I tell myself about myself? Is there a gift God has given me, a talent, a success, even a spiritual consolation, that I have been holding as if it were my own? And the other side of the parable: is my vessel full, or have I been carrying a lamp with nothing in it, trusting that there will be time to buy oil later?

Do. Do one good thing today that no one will ever know about, and tell no one. If you are praised today, give the praise back to God at once, in a single silent word. If you have been putting off Confession, go this week; it is the market that is still open. Read a page of St. Gertrude’s Spiritual Exercises or of the Herald of Divine Love, slowly, as a prayer rather than as a book.

Pray. The Collect of the day, with its plea to wash away cordis nostri maculas, the stains of our heart. Then the words of the Psalmist that Gertrude loved: “Not to us, O Lord, not to us; but to thy name give glory” (Ps. 113:9).

Aspiration. Ecce sponsus venit: exite obviam Christo Domino. “Behold the Bridegroom cometh: go ye forth to meet Christ the Lord.”

Devote. Gertrude is one of the first great witnesses to devotion to the Sacred Heart of Jesus. Make an act of consecration to the Sacred Heart today, or pray the Litany of the Sacred Heart. November is the month of the Holy Souls, and Gertrude prayed for them with an ardour the Church has never forgotten; offer a prayer for the faithful departed, especially for those who have no one to remember them, and ask St. Gertrude, who sought her oil only in the Heart of Christ, to obtain for you a heart that glories in nothing but Him.


If you wish to go deeper: the Lives of the Saints path tells the story of St. Gertrude and the school of Helfta: her childhood oblation, her conversion of 1281, her friendship with St. Mechtilde of Hackeborn, the composition of the Legatus divinæ pietatis and the Exercitia spiritualia, and the long confusion of her life with that of her abbess. The Spiritual Practices and Devotions path takes up her seven Spiritual Exercises, from the renewal of Baptism to the preparation for death, as a structured rule of prayer, and traces the devotion to the Sacred Heart from Helfta to Paray-le-Monial. The Theology and Doctrine path treats Augustine’s doctrine of grace in its classic text, Qui gloriatur, in Domino glorietur, and the theology of consecrated virginity in Ambrose, Jerome, and St. Thomas. The Sacred Liturgy path considers the Common of Virgins and the ancient rite of the consecration of virgins, which Gertrude renewed in prayer every year.

Sources. Scripture is cited from the Douay-Rheims, with the Vulgate. The Fathers are given in paraphrase with their loci: St. Augustine, De spiritu et littera 7.11, De gratia et libero arbitrio 6.15, In Iohannis Evangelium tractatus 13.12, Sermo 93; St. John Chrysostom, Homiliæ in epistulam II ad Corinthios 22-23, Homiliæ in Matthæum 78; Ambrosiaster, Commentarius in epistulam II ad Corinthios (on 10:18); Theodoret of Cyrus, Interpretatio in epistulam II ad Corinthios (on 11:2); St. Ambrose, De virginibus I.6.31; St. Jerome, Epistula 22.25 and Commentarius in Matthæum IV (on 25:5-9); St. Hilary of Poitiers, Commentarius in Matthæum 27.4-5; St. Gregory the Great, Homiliæ in Evangelia 12. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue. For St. Gertrude: Legatus divinæ pietatis I.11, II.1, IV.4; Exercitia spiritualia III; the Roman Martyrology; Butler’s Lives of the Saints.

Prudentes virgines, aptate vestras lampades.

Share the Post:

Related Posts