Skip to content

Riches Held Loosely, Lamps Held High


Feria IV infra Hebdomadam VII post Octavam Pentecostes — S. Henrici Imperatoris Confessoris, III classis (15 July)


I. Liturgical Context

The Sanctorale interrupts the green ferias of the Seventh Week after Pentecost with an emperor. This is itself a small argument. St. Henry II (973–1024), last of the Ottonians, crowned Emperor by Benedict VIII in 1014, is placed before the Church not as a penitent who fled the world but as a man who held the world’s highest office and was not held by it. The Common of a Confessor not a Bishop supplies the Mass, and the choice of lessons — Ecclesiasticus on the rich man who is found blameless, and Luke on the servants who wait with lamps burning — is a commentary on his life rather than a coincidence of the Common.

The feria’s ordinary character matters too. This is a Wednesday in a long stretch of Sundays after Pentecost, the season in which the Church catechizes the baptized in the ordinary labor of perseverance. Henry belongs here: sanctity in the midst of administration, of war, of synods and endowments, of a marriage (to St. Cunegunde) and a crown.

II. The Lesson — Ecclesiasticus 31:8–11

Beatus vir qui inventus est sine macula, et qui post aurum non abiit, nec speravit in pecunia et thesauris.

“Blessed is the man that is found without blemish: and that hath not gone after gold, nor put his trust in money nor in treasures.”

The Wisdom writer does not say blessed is the man who has no gold. He says blessed is the man who has not gone after itqui post aurum non abiit. The distinction is precise and the Church has always guarded it. Wealth is not the blemish; the going-after is. And then the text asks the question that hangs over the whole passage: Quis est hic, et laudabimus eum? — “Who is he, and we will praise him? for he hath done wonderful things in his life.”

The interrogative is not rhetorical despair. It is a genuine rarity claim. Such a man exists, but he is uncommon enough that when found he deserves the Church’s public praise. Today the Church answers the question by pointing at Henry.

St. Ambrose, treating riches in De Nabuthae, presses the point that the possessor of wealth is a steward and not an owner; what is superfluous to him is owed to the poor by justice and not merely by generosity (see De Nabuthae 1, PL 14). St. Basil, in the homily on Luke’s rich fool (Homilia in illud Lucae: Destruam horrea mea, PG 31), argues that the goods a man locks away are already, in the divine accounting, the property of the hungry. St. John Chrysostom returns to this constantly in the homilies on Matthew: the rich man is not condemned for having but for retaining against the claim of need (see Homiliae in Matthaeum, PG 57–58).

Henry’s biography reads as though he had these texts before him. He founded and endowed the see of Bamberg, giving away imperial patrimony to do it. He gave to Cluny. He restored Merseburg. The gold passed through his hands and did not stick to them — tentatus est in illo et perfectus est, “he hath been tried thereby, and made perfect.”

That word tentatus — tried, tempted — deserves weight. Scripture treats wealth as a trial rather than as a neutral circumstance. The emperor was tested precisely by the thing that would have damned a lesser man.

III. The Gospel — Luke 12:35–40

Sint lumbi vestri praecincti, et lucernae ardentes in manibus vestris.

“Let your loins be girt, and lamps burning in your hands. And you yourselves like to men who wait for their lord, when he shall return from the wedding: that when he cometh and knocketh, they may open to him immediately.”

Two images, and the Fathers read them as two virtues.

The girded loins: St. Gregory the Great, in the homilies on the Gospels, takes lumbi praecincti as the restraint of concupiscence — the loins are girt when carnal desire is bound by continence (see Homiliae in Evangelia XIII, PL 76). The burning lamps he reads as good works shining before men, charity made visible. Girding is what a man does to himself; the lamp is what he holds out to others. Continence and charity, the interior and the exterior, and the Gospel demands both together.

Then the astonishing verse: Beati servi illi, quos cum venerit dominus, invenerit vigilantes: amen dico vobis, quod praecinget se, et faciet illos discumbere, et transiens ministrabit illis — “Blessed are those servants, whom the Lord when he cometh, shall find watching. Amen I say to you, that he will gird himself, and make them sit down to meat, and passing will minister unto them.”

The master girds himself. The servants who girded their loins in vigilance find that the Lord takes up the servant’s belt and waits on them at table. St. Ambrose, expounding Luke, sees here the reversal that the Incarnation already accomplished and the eschaton will consummate: He who took the form of a servant serves still, and the reward of watchfulness is to be served by God (see Expositio Evangelii secundum Lucam VII, CCSL 14).

And the closing turn: qua hora non putatis, Filius hominis veniet — “at what hour you think not, the Son of man will come.” Gregory’s pastoral conclusion is the one the Church has never improved upon: the day is hidden that every day may be watched.

IV. Synthesis

Put the two lessons together and the shape of Henry’s sanctity emerges.

Ecclesiasticus asks who is the man who possesses without grasping? Luke answers the man whose loins are girt and whose lamp is lit — that is, the man whose interior desire is bound and whose exterior goods are burning up in charity rather than being hoarded. The lamp consumes its oil. That is precisely what a lamp is for. Wealth that is not being consumed in the service of God and neighbor is not a lamp; it is a jar of oil in a cellar, and the master returns to find the house dark.

In the Thomistic frame: creatures come forth from God and return to Him (exitus–reditus), and temporal goods are ordered as means to that return. The disorder of avarice is not that the miser loves gold too much but that he loves it finally — as an end rather than a means, terminating in the creature the motion that should pass through it back to God. Henry’s endowments are the reditus enacted in coin: gold received from God as means, spent as means, returned as worship. St. Thomas treats the ordering of exterior goods to the last end throughout the treatise on beatitude (ST I-II q. 2), where he shows that riches cannot constitute man’s happiness because they exist for the sake of something further.

This is why an emperor can be a confessor. Sanctity does not require the absence of the world’s goods but their right ordering. Henry did not have less than other emperors; he held it differently.

And the vigilance clause guards against the obvious counterfeit — the man who gives generously and calls the account settled. The Gospel does not say blessed are the servants who gave; it says blessed are the servants whom the Lord when He cometh shall find watching. Almsgiving is not a substitute for readiness. The lamp must be burning when He knocks, not have burned impressively last year.

V. Devotional Application

The reflection presses in three directions.

On possession. Ask of any good thing you hold: is this burning, or is it stored? The question is not whether you have money, a house, a reputation, a position. The question is whether it is being spent toward God. What is superfluous to you is, in the Fathers’ accounting, already owed elsewhere.

On the girded loins. Interior discipline is not optional decoration on top of generosity. Henry’s chastity in marriage (whatever one makes of the later legend of a perpetually virginal union — see below) and his continence in office are of a piece with his almsgiving. A man who gives away gold while his desires remain ungirt has half a Gospel.

On the hour. Vigilance is a habit, not an event. Gregory’s insight is that the hiddenness of the hour is a mercy, because it makes every hour the hour. The practical form of this is the daily examination of conscience and the frequent renewal of intention — living so that the knock at the door would find nothing that needed hasty rearranging.

VI. Collect

NON-AUTHENTICATED — pending collation against a printed 1962 Missale Romanum. Provided from the Common of a Confessor not a Bishop as orientation only; the proper Collect for S. Henrici must be verified.

Deus, qui hodierna die beatum Henricum Confessorem tuum e terreni culmine imperii ad regnum aeternum transtulisti: te supplices exoramus; ut, sicut illum, gratiae tuae ubertate praeventum, illecebras saeculi superare fecisti, ita nos facias, ejus imitatione, mundi hujus blandimenta vitare, et ad te puris mentibus pervenire.

“O God, who on this day didst translate blessed Henry, Thy Confessor, from the summit of earthly empire to the eternal kingdom: we humbly beseech Thee; that, as Thou didst make him, prevented by the abundance of Thy grace, to overcome the allurements of the world, so Thou wouldst make us, by his imitation, to shun the enticements of this world, and to come to Thee with pure minds.”

VII. Aspiration

Domine, aurum meum in lucernam verte, et lucernam in manu mea ardentem serva, donec pulses.

“Lord, turn my gold into a lamp, and keep the lamp burning in my hand, until Thou knock.”

VIII. For Further Study

Patristic:

  • St. Gregory the Great, Homiliae in Evangelia XIII (PL 76) — the governing patristic reading of Luke 12:35ff.; girded loins as continence, lamps as good works
  • St. Ambrose, Expositio Evangelii secundum Lucam VII (CCSL 14) — the Lord who girds Himself to serve
  • St. Ambrose, De Nabuthae (PL 14) — stewardship and the claim of the poor
  • St. Basil, Homilia in illud Lucae: Destruam horrea mea (PG 31) — hoarded goods as stolen goods
  • St. John Chrysostom, Homiliae in Matthaeum (PG 57–58) — the recurring treatment of riches and retention

Scholastic:

  • St. Thomas, ST I-II q. 2 (riches cannot constitute beatitude); II-II q. 118 (avarice) — article-level verification remains a pre-publication task

Sources for Henry:

  • Vita Sancti Heinrici (Adalbert of Bamberg, MGH SS 4) — the canonization-era Life, tendentious and to be read critically
  • Thietmar of Merseburg, Chronicon (MGH SS rer. Germ. n.s. 9) — contemporary, hostile in places, the best witness

Forward links:

  • Sacred Liturgy path: the Common of a Confessor not a Bishop and the theology of the non-martyr’s sanctity
  • Lives of the Saints path: St. Cunegunde (3 March) as companion Life; the Ottonian imperial cluster
  • Theology and Doctrine path: the treatise on avarice and the ordering of exterior goods (ST II-II q. 118)

Share the Post:

Related Posts