Skip to content

Planted in the House of the Lord

A reflection for the Presentation of the Blessed Virgin Mary — In Præsentatione Beatæ Mariæ Virginis, III classis (21 November), Sabbato infra Hebdomadam VI quæ superfuit post Epiphaniam

An old story, loved in the East for fifteen centuries, tells how a little girl of three years went up to the Temple in Jerusalem. Her parents, Joachim and Anna, had long been childless, and they had promised that if God gave them a child they would give the child back to Him. When the time came, the story says, they led her up the steps of the sanctuary with a company of young girls carrying lamps, so that the child would not look back and long for home. She did not look back. The priest received her and blessed her, and set her down on the third step of the altar, and she danced there for joy, and all the house of Israel loved her. From that day, the story goes on, she lived in the precincts of the Temple, and was fed as a dove is fed, and received her food from the hand of an angel.

This story comes to us from a second-century writing called the Protoevangelium of James (chapters 7 and 8). The Church has never received that book as Scripture, and the details of the lamps, the dancing, and the angel’s bread belong to pious tradition, not to history. But the Church has received something beneath the story, and has made a feast of it: that the Mother of God was given to God from her earliest years, and that she belonged to Him before she belonged to anyone else. St. Augustine, who knew nothing of the lamps and the third step, reached the same conclusion from the Gospel itself. When the Angel told Mary she would conceive a Son, she asked, How shall this be done, because I know not man? (Luke 1:34). She would never have asked this, Augustine reasons, if she had not already dedicated her virginity to God (De sancta virginitate 4.4). The Presentation is the feast of that first dedication: the morning offering of a whole life, made before the Annunciation, and made ready for it.

The feast was born in the East. In Jerusalem, on the twenty-first of November in the year 543, the Emperor Justinian dedicated a great new church of the Mother of God near the site of the Temple, and the memory of Mary’s entrance into the Temple came to be kept on the anniversary. The Greeks still call the feast the Eisodos, the Entrance of the Theotokos, and count it among the great feasts of their year. It came to the West late and by a winding road. A French knight and diplomat, Philippe de Mézières, who had seen it kept in the East, brought it to Pope Gregory XI at Avignon, where it was celebrated in 1372. Sixtus IV admitted it more widely a century later. St. Pius V, in his reform of the Breviary in 1568, removed it from the Roman calendar, and Sixtus V restored it in 1585. It has stood in the calendar ever since: one of the quiet feasts on which the Latin and Greek Churches keep the same mystery on the same day.

The Mass is Salve, sancta Parens, from the Common of Our Lady, with a proper Collect, and the vestments are white. It falls on a Saturday, the day the Church has given to Our Lady for more than a thousand years, so that her weekly day and her feast coincide. It is the Saturday of the sixth week after the Epiphany, the last of those weeks resumed at the end of the year. Tomorrow is the last Sunday after Pentecost, the last Sunday of the Church’s year. Its Gospel will speak of the abomination of desolation, standing in the holy place (Matt. 24:15), and of a Temple that would not keep one stone upon another. Today, on the eve of that Gospel, the Church shows us a little girl going up into that same Temple. Before we hear how the house of stone will be left desolate, we are shown the living house that will never be left desolate at all.

The readings of today’s Mass have been read several times this autumn, on the Saturdays of Our Lady. Today they are heard in a new key. On those Saturdays they spoke of where Wisdom came to rest. Today they speak of the place where the resting-place was itself made ready.

I. In habitatione sancta coram ipso ministravi: the Epistle

“From the beginning, and before the world, was I created, and unto the world to come I shall not cease to be, and in the holy dwelling place I have ministered before him. And so was I established in Sion, and in the holy city likewise I rested, and my power was in Jerusalem. And I took root in an honourable people, and in the portion of my God his inheritance, and my abode is in the full assembly of saints.” (Ecclus. 24:14-16)

Whose words these are. In the twenty-fourth chapter of Ecclesiasticus, Wisdom sings her own praise. In their first and highest sense the words belong to the eternal Son, the Wisdom of the Father, the brightness of his glory, and the figure of his substance (Heb. 1:3). But the Church has always read them also of Mary, in the Masses and the Office of her feasts, because the eternal Wisdom chose her for His dwelling. What is said of the Word, from eternity, is said of her in a lesser and borrowed way, in time: she was in God’s plan from the beginning, chosen before the world, and prepared for Him who was to dwell in her. This is why the Church can sing of the Mother in the words of the Son. She has nothing that she did not receive from Him, and she received everything for Him.

On the other Saturdays of this season, the first line of the reading carried the weight. Today it is the third: in habitatione sancta coram ipso ministravi, “in the holy dwelling place I have ministered before him.” No line of Scripture could be better chosen for this morning. The holy dwelling place is the Temple; the ministry before him is the service of God within it. The Church takes these words, written centuries before Mary’s birth, and lays them like a garland at the foot of the Temple steps where the child is going up.

What kind of ministry? Mary was not a priest, and she offered no sacrifice in the Temple. The ministry of the Law belonged to the sons of Aaron. Her ministry was of another kind: the service of a heart wholly given. St. John Damascene, the last of the Greek Fathers, describes it in a single sentence. Planted in the house of God, he says, and nourished there by the Holy Spirit, she grew like a fruitful olive tree, and became the dwelling of every virtue, because she turned her mind away from every desire of this world and of the flesh (De fide orthodoxa IV.14). He is thinking of the Psalm: But I, as a fruitful olive tree in the house of God, have hoped in the mercy of God for ever (Ps. 51:10). The olive in the Temple court does not do anything spectacular. It stands, and it is fed, and it bears fruit. That was her ministry.

St. Ambrose, writing to his sister Marcellina on the life of virgins, gives the portrait of Mary that the Latin Church loved best. He does not describe her in the Temple; he describes what kind of girl she was. She was humble of heart, he says, grave in speech, sparing of words, and eager in reading. She put her hope not in riches but in the prayers of the poor. She was diligent in her work, modest in her speech, and she sought God, not men, as the witness of her soul. She hurt no one, wished well to all, honoured her elders, and envied none of her equals. She went out of her home only to go to the house of God (De virginibus II.2.7-9). Ambrose sets this portrait before the virgins of Milan as the pattern of their own life: let the life of Mary be to you as virginity itself, set forth in a picture. This is what ministering before him means. It is a way of living in which the whole of one’s life is spent in the presence of God.

And so was I established in Sion. Firmata sum: made firm, set fast. A child of three is not firm in anything. But the Church sees in this child a soul that God had made firm from its first instant. The Church holds as dogma that Mary was preserved from all stain of original sin in the first instant of her conception, by a singular grace and privilege of Almighty God (Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus, 1854). St. Thomas teaches that the Mother of God received so great a fullness of grace because she was to be the nearest of all creatures to the source of grace, Christ Himself (Summa Theologiæ III, q. 27). So when she went up into Sion, she did not go to be made holy. She went because she was already holy, and holiness belongs in the house of God. The Temple did not sanctify Mary. Mary, without knowing it, came to sanctify the Temple, as the Ark had once been carried into the house Solomon built for it.

And in the holy city likewise I rested. St. Germanus of Constantinople, the great patriarch who suffered for the holy images, preached on this feast in the eighth century. He loved to set the two temples side by side: the temple made with hands, and the living temple that was entering it. The child carried up the steps, he says, is the true sanctuary of which the old one was only the figure. The Holy of Holies was a room with an Ark in it, and the Ark held the tables of the Law and the manna; Mary will be the dwelling that holds the Lawgiver and the Bread from heaven Himself (In præsentationem Sanctæ Deiparæ, Homily I). The old house of God receives the new, and does not yet know it. The figures of the Law are standing round her, waiting, like servants who have kept a house clean for a master they have never seen.

I took root in an honourable people. Radicavi. Mary was not a stranger to the Temple. She was a daughter of Israel, of the house of David, heir to the patriarchs and the prophets. She took root in that people and in its worship. Everything she knew of God, before the Angel came, she knew from the Law and the Psalms and the prayer of the Temple. The Church does not set Mary over against the Old Covenant; she makes her its flower. All the long faithfulness of Israel, from Abraham to the last of the prophets, ripened in her.

And her parents’ gift is itself rooted in Israel’s memory. The story of the Presentation is told on the pattern of another story, one that is Scripture. Anna, the wife of Elcana, was barren, and she prayed in the Temple at Silo with such grief that the priest thought she was drunk. She vowed that if God gave her a son, she would give him back to the Lord all the days of his life. God heard her, and when the child Samuel was weaned, she brought him up to the house of the Lord and said: For this child did I pray, and the Lord hath granted me my petition. Therefore I also have lent him to the Lord all the days of his life (1 Kings 1:27-28). Another Anna, the tradition says, did the same for her daughter. Whatever the details, the lesson is Scripture’s own: what God gives in answer to prayer is given most fully when it is given back.

II. Quinimmo beati: the Gospel

“At that time, as Jesus was speaking to the multitudes, a certain woman from the crowd, lifting up her voice, said to him: Blessed is the womb that bore thee, and the paps that gave thee suck. But he said: Yea rather, blessed are they who hear the word of God, and keep it.” (Luke 11:27-28)

As he spoke these things. St. Luke places this cry of the woman at a moment of conflict. Our Lord has just cast out a devil, and some in the crowd have said He casts out devils by Beelzebub. He has answered them, and has told a dark parable of an unclean spirit that goes out of a man, finds no rest, and comes back to find its old house swept and garnished, and brings seven worse spirits with it, and the last state of that man becomes worse than the first (Luke 11:24-26). It is just then, as he spoke these things, that the woman cries out.

St. Bede, whose commentary on this passage the Church reads at Matins on Our Lady’s feasts, sees the contrast at once. While the scribes and Pharisees were tempting the Lord and blaspheming Him, he says, this woman confessed His Incarnation with such sincerity and faith that she put to shame both the slander of the leaders who stood there and the unbelief of the heretics who would come later, and deny that He had taken true flesh from His Mother (In Lucæ Evangelium Expositio IV, on 11:27). Bede says she stands for the Church herself, who lifts her voice from the crowd of the nations to bless the womb of the Virgin.

There is something else in the placing of the cry. Our Lord has just spoken of a house swept and empty, into which evil returns because nothing good has come to live there. And the woman, without knowing why, answers by praising the one house that was never empty: the house that was swept clean from the first instant, and then filled. Mary is the opposite of the swept and garnished house of the parable. She is the house that was made ready and then inhabited, by God Himself. That is the mystery of today’s feast. The child is going up to the Temple to be a house for God.

Blessed is the womb that bore thee. The woman is right, and the Church has never stopped repeating her. Beata viscera Mariæ Virginis, quæ portaverunt æterni Patris Filium, the Communion of today’s Mass will sing: “Blessed is the womb of the Virgin Mary, which bore the Son of the eternal Father.” Mary herself had foretold it: Behold from henceforth all generations shall call me blessed (Luke 1:48). The woman in the crowd is the first of those generations to speak after the birth of Christ. She praises the Son by praising His Mother, which is the oldest form of devotion to Mary there is.

Yea rather. But Our Lord answers, Quinimmo: “Yea rather,” or “Rather still.” The word does not deny what the woman said. It goes beyond it. St. Bede says so explicitly: the Lord confirms the woman’s praise, and then shows her a deeper blessedness. Mary is blessed, Bede says, because she bore the Word of God in her body for a time; but she is more blessed because she kept Him always in her love (In Lucæ Evangelium Expositio IV, on 11:28).

The Fathers return to this point again and again, and they are entirely at one. St. Augustine says that her motherhood would have profited Mary nothing if she had not carried Christ more blessedly in her heart than in her flesh (De sancta virginitate 3.3). Preaching to his people, he went further: it was a greater thing for Mary to have been the disciple of Christ than to have been His Mother, and she was blessed, not because the Word was made flesh in her and dwelt among us, but because she heard the word of God and kept it (Sermo 72A.7). St. Leo the Great puts it in a phrase that the Latin Church has never forgotten: the Virgin conceived her Son in her mind before she conceived Him in her body (Sermo 21.1). Faith came first; flesh followed.

None of this lessens Mary. It is the highest praise that can be given her. For of all those who ever heard the word of God and kept it, she heard it most purely and kept it most faithfully. Twice St. Luke tells us that she kept all these words, pondering them in her heart (Luke 2:19, 51). The woman in the crowd blessed her for one thing; the Lord blessed her for two, and the second contains the first. She is the Mother of God because she is first and most perfectly the hearer of God.

And here is the bond with today’s feast. Where did Mary learn to hear and keep the word of God? The Church’s feast gives the answer: in the house of God, from her earliest years. Whatever the details of her childhood, she grew up in the prayer of Israel, in the Psalms and the Law and the Prophets. When the Angel came, the Word he brought found a soul that had been listening for years. She knew how to receive a word from God, because she had spent her whole life receiving words from God and keeping them. The Fiat of the Annunciation did not come out of nowhere. It was the harvest of a long hearing.

This is why the Gospel and the feast belong together. The Presentation is not only an event in Mary’s childhood. It is the beginning of her discipleship. She went up into the house of God to hear the word of God. She came down from it, years later, ready to keep it in the most literal way any creature ever has: by keeping the Word made flesh in her own womb, and then in her arms, and then in her heart at the foot of the Cross.

III. The Mass as a whole: given back to the Giver

St. Thomas built the Summa Theologiæ on the great circle of exitus and reditus: all things come forth from God, and all things return to Him, through Christ, who as man is our way back to God (Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue). Today’s feast traces that circle in its simplest and most human form. It is the circle of a gift given and given back.

The going-forth is God’s. The Epistle begins before the world, in the eternal counsel of God, where the Wisdom of the Father was begotten and where the Mother of that Wisdom was foreseen and chosen. In time, the gift goes forth again: God gives a child to Joachim and Anna after long years of barrenness. Every child is a gift of God, but this one was given as an answer to tears, like Samuel, like Isaac, like John the Baptist. Mary herself is an exitus, a gift coming forth from God’s hand into the world.

The return is the Presentation. The parents give back to God the gift He gave them. And the child, as soon as she is able, gives herself back as well; the tradition of the Church has always understood the feast as the first free consecration of Mary’s own will. St. Augustine reads her question to the Angel as the sign of a dedication already made. That return to God is the turning-point of the circle. The gift does not stop with the one who receives it. It goes home.

What closes the circle is the Gospel. The return to God is not completed by going up a flight of steps. It is completed by hearing the word of God, and keeping it. The Temple was the place of the return, but the heart is where it is finished. And in Mary it was finished in a way that went beyond anything her parents could have foreseen. She gave herself back to God, and God gave Himself to her. The child who went up into the house of the Lord became the house of the Lord. The reditus of one little girl became the exitus of the Son into the world: He came forth from the Father, and dwelt in the Virgin, so that He could lead all things back to the Father. That is why the Epistle can end in the full assembly of saints. Her return opened the road for ours.

And so tomorrow’s Gospel need not frighten us. The Temple of stone was left desolate, as the Lord foretold, and not one stone remained upon another. But the living Temple that went up into it on this day was never desolate. Unto the world to come I shall not cease to be.

IV. The Collects

Deus, qui beatam Mariam semper Virginem, Spiritus Sancti habitaculum, hodierna die in templo præsentari voluisti: præsta, quæsumus; ut, eius intercessione, in templo gloriæ tuæ præsentari mereamur.

“O God, who didst will that on this day blessed Mary ever Virgin, the dwelling place of the Holy Ghost, should be presented in the Temple: grant, we beseech Thee, that by her intercession we may be found worthy to be presented in the temple of Thy glory.”

The Collect is built on a single word used twice: præsentari, to be presented. Mary was presented in the temple of Jerusalem; we ask to be presented in the temple of God’s glory. Her Presentation was a beginning; ours will be an end. The whole Christian life lies between these two presentations, the first in the earthly house of God and the last in the heavenly one.

Notice what the Collect calls her: Spiritus Sancti habitaculum, the dwelling place of the Holy Ghost. The Church says she was already this when she went up the steps. The Temple she entered was a house God had once filled with His glory; but the child entering it was a house God was filling with His Spirit at that very moment. And notice the verb: voluisti, “Thou didst will.” The feast is not first about the parents’ piety, or even about the child’s. It is about God’s will, which wanted this to happen, and arranged it. Every consecration we make is first God’s desire before it is ours.

Tua, Domine, propitiatione, et beatæ Mariæ semper Virginis intercessione, ad perpetuam atque præsentem hæc oblatio nobis proficiat prosperitatem et pacem.

“By Thy gracious mercy, O Lord, and the intercession of blessed Mary ever Virgin, may this oblation profit us unto prosperity and peace, both now and for ever.”

The Secret asks that our offering profit us both now and for ever, perpetuam atque præsentem. The word præsentem sounds quietly in the background of the feast: what is present now, and what is presented. As the bread and wine are presented at the altar, so Mary was presented in the Temple. Both are offerings that God will change into something far greater than the one who offered them could have imagined.

Sumptis, Domine, salutis nostræ subsidiis: da, quæsumus, beatæ Mariæ semper Virginis patrociniis nos ubique protegi; in cuius veneratione hæc tuæ obtulimus maiestati.

“Having received, O Lord, the helps of our salvation, grant, we beseech Thee, that we may everywhere be protected by the patronage of blessed Mary ever Virgin, in whose honour we have offered these gifts to Thy majesty.”

After Communion, the Church asks for Mary’s protection ubique, everywhere. She who was kept safe in the house of God is asked to keep us safe wherever we go, outside the house of God, in the world. And we have just done, in a small way, what she did: we have received the Word into ourselves. The Postcommunion asks that we may keep what we have received.

V. A word for practice

Examine. When did I last give myself to God, freely and on purpose, and not only out of habit? Is there any part of my life I have never offered Him: my work, my time, my children, my future, my fears? Do I treat what God has given me as mine to keep, or as His to be given back? When I hear the word of God at Mass, or in Scripture, do I let it pass through me, or do I keep it, carry it home, ponder it in my heart? Is my soul like the house in the parable, swept but empty, or is it inhabited?

Do. Make an act of consecration today, in your own words or in a set form, offering your whole self to God through the hands of Mary. If you have children, offer them to God again today, as Joachim and Anna did, and ask that they may belong to Him before they belong to anyone else. Take one sentence from today’s Mass, such as Blessed are they who hear the word of God, and keep it, and carry it with you through the day, returning to it whenever you are idle. Before the last Sunday of the year tomorrow, and before Advent begins next Sunday, set aside a fixed time each day of Advent for reading the Gospel slowly, as Mary listened.

Pray. The Collect of the day, asking to be presented one day in the temple of God’s glory. Then the Magnificat, the song of the girl who learned in the house of God how to rejoice in God her Saviour.

Aspiration. Beati qui audiunt verbum Dei, et custodiunt illud. “Blessed are they who hear the word of God, and keep it.”

Devote. It has long been a custom, begun by Father Jean-Jacques Olier and the priests of Saint-Sulpice in seventeenth-century Paris, for clerics to renew their consecration to God on this feast, in imitation of Mary’s offering in the Temple. Pray today for priests and seminarians, that they may renew the gift of themselves and keep it faithfully. Pray for religious sisters, especially those who were given to God young, and for all consecrated virgins. In this month of the Holy Souls, remember also the parents who have died, who gave their children to God, and ask Our Lady to present them in the temple of His glory.


If you wish to go deeper: the Sacred Liturgy path considers the Common of Our Lady, Salve, sancta Parens, and how the Church reads the Wisdom books of the Old Testament in the Masses and Office of Mary’s feasts. The Theology and Doctrine path treats St. Thomas on Mary’s sanctification and her fullness of grace, the definition of the Immaculate Conception, and the Fathers on Mary as the hearer of the word, who conceived in mind before she conceived in body. The Church History path follows the feast from Justinian’s church in Jerusalem through Avignon, the suppression of St. Pius V, and the restoration of Sixtus V. The Spiritual Practices and Devotions path takes up the practice of consecration to Jesus through Mary, and the Sulpician tradition of renewal on this day. The East-West Comparative path considers the Eisodos as one of the twelve great feasts of the Byzantine year, and what the two Churches share in keeping it on the same day.

Sources. Scripture is cited from the Douay-Rheims, with the Vulgate. The Fathers are given in paraphrase with their loci: St. Augustine, De sancta virginitate 3.3 and 4.4, and Sermo 72A.7; St. Leo the Great, Sermo 21.1; St. Ambrose, De virginibus II.2.7-9; St. Bede, In Lucæ Evangelium Expositio IV (on 11:27-28); St. Germanus of Constantinople, In præsentationem Sanctæ Deiparæ, Homily I; St. John Damascene, De fide orthodoxa IV.14. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue, and III, q. 27. Magisterial text: Pius IX, Ineffabilis Deus (1854). Apocryphal tradition: the Protoevangelium of James, chapters 7-8, cited as pious tradition only. Liturgical history: the Roman Breviary and Martyrology for 21 November.

In habitatione sancta coram ipso ministravi.

Share the Post:

Related Posts