A reflection for the Feast of St. Felix of Valois, Confessor — S. Felicis de Valois Confessoris, III classis (20 November), Feria VI infra Hebdomadam VI quæ superfuit post Epiphaniam
In the forest of Gandelu, in the diocese of Meaux, about sixty miles north-east of Paris, there is a spring called Cerfroid. Toward the end of the twelfth century an old hermit named Felix was living there in a cell he had built for himself, praying, fasting, and taking in a few disciples. In the last decade of that century a younger man came to find him: John of Matha, a Provençal priest and a doctor of the University of Paris. At his first Mass, John had seen Christ holding two captives by the hand, one white and one black, as though He were asking for them to be set free. John came to Cerfroid to ask Felix what the vision meant, and the two of them spent three years there in prayer before they understood what God wanted. Then they went to Rome together. On the seventeenth of December, 1198, Pope Innocent III approved their rule, and the Order of the Most Holy Trinity for the Redemption of Captives was born.
The new order had a single purpose, written into its rule: to ransom Christians held captive by the Moors in North Africa and Spain. Every house of the Order was to divide its income into three parts. Two parts would keep the friars and serve the poor and the sick. The third part, the tertia pars, was set aside for one thing only, to buy back captives. The friars wore a white habit with a cross of red and blue on the breast, and their motto was Gloria tibi Trinitas, et captivis libertas: “Glory to Thee, O Trinity, and freedom to the captives.” Within a few years of their founding the first Trinitarian redemptors had crossed the sea to Morocco and returned with men they had ransomed. Over the centuries that followed, the Order bought back many thousands. One of them, in 1580, was a Spanish soldier who had spent five years as a slave in Algiers; his name was Miguel de Cervantes.
John went out on the roads and across the sea. Felix stayed behind at Cerfroid, governing the motherhouse, training the novices, and praying for the work. He died there on the fourth of November, 1212, very old. The tradition of the Order holds that he was born in 1127 of the house of the Counts of Valois, a kinsman of the kings of France, and that he gave up his name and his inheritance to become a hermit. Historians have long doubted his royal descent, and it is best kept as a pious tradition of the Order rather than a fact of history. What is certain is what he did with the end of his life: he gave it to the captives. His cult, and St. John’s, was confirmed by the Holy See in the seventeenth century, and his feast was extended to the whole Church.
Other legends belong to the same pious tradition. It is told that Felix and John were sitting beside the spring at Cerfroid when a white stag came down to drink, bearing between its antlers a cross of red and blue, and that this was the sign given them for their habit. The Roman Breviary records another: that one night, on the vigil of the Nativity of Our Lady, the brethren slept through the bell for Matins, and Felix, coming into the choir alone, found the Blessed Virgin there with a company of angels, all wearing the habit of the Order, and sang the Office with them. These stories cannot be proved, but they tell the truth about the man. He was a hermit who loved the hidden life, and he was given a work that sent his sons into the slave markets of Africa.
The Mass is Os justi, from the Common of Confessors, with a proper Collect and proper lessons, and the vestments are white. The Introit is from the thirty-sixth Psalm: “The mouth of the just shall meditate wisdom: and his tongue shall speak judgment. The law of his God is in his heart” (Ps. 36:30-31). The lessons were chosen for a founder of a ransoming order: St. Paul on the Apostles made a spectacle to the world, and Our Lord on selling what we possess and giving alms.
It is Friday of the sixth week after the Epiphany, resumed in these last weeks of the year. Yesterday we kept St. Elizabeth of Hungary, and heard of the man who sold all that he had to buy the field. Today the Gospel tells us to sell what we possess, and the Epistle shows us what the Apostles looked like after they had done it. Tomorrow is the Presentation of Our Lady, and on Sunday the Church will close her year with the last Gospel of the end of the world.
I. Spectaculum facti sumus: the Epistle
“Brethren: I think that God hath set forth us apostles, the last, as it were men appointed to death: we are made a spectacle to the world, and to angels, and to men. We are fools for Christ’s sake, but you are wise in Christ: we are weak, but you are strong: you are honourable, but we without honour. Even unto this hour we both hunger and thirst, and are naked, and are buffeted, and have no fixed abode; and we labour, working with our own hands: we are reviled, and we bless; we are persecuted, and we suffer it. We are blasphemed, and we entreat; we are made as the refuse of this world, the offscouring of all even until now. I write not these things to confound you; but I admonish you as my dearest children.” (1 Cor. 4:9-14)
God hath set forth us apostles, the last, as it were men appointed to death. St. Paul is writing to a church that has grown proud. The Corinthians had begun to think of themselves as already rich, already reigning, already wise; a few verses earlier he says to them with bitter irony, You are now full; you are now become rich; you reign without us (1 Cor. 4:8). Against their self-satisfaction he sets a picture of the Apostles. St. John Chrysostom, preaching on this passage at Antioch, says that Paul is drawing on the image of the arena. At the end of the public games, after the beasts and the gladiators, the men condemned to death were brought out last, to be killed before the crowd. That is how God has set forth the Apostles: the last, like condemned men brought into the amphitheatre with no hope of leaving it alive (Homiliæ in epistulam I ad Corinthios 12.2).
We are made a spectacle to the world, and to angels, and to men. Spectaculum facti sumus: the Greek word is theatron, a show in the theatre. But Chrysostom points out how great the theatre is. It is not a few thousand Corinthians in their seats. It is the whole world, and the angels too, looking down on the struggle (Hom. in I Cor. 12.2). The Apostles suffer before a heavenly audience. St. Cyprian, writing from Carthage in the persecution of Valerian to bishops and priests who had been condemned to the mines of Numidia, told them the same thing: that God looks on at their struggle with pleasure, and the angels and Christ Himself stand by them as spectators and helpers in the contest (Epistula 76). Men who were slaves in the mines, in chains, half-starved, their heads half-shaved, were the great spectacle of heaven.
This is the first point of contact with St. Felix. The captives whom his Order went to ransom were Christians in exactly this condition: sold in the markets, set to work in the galleys and the quarries, beaten, mocked for their faith, often pressed to apostatize. In the eyes of the world they were the refuse of the earth. In the eyes of heaven they were a spectacle to the angels. The Trinitarian friars went down into that arena to bring them out.
We are fools for Christ’s sake, but you are wise in Christ. The irony continues. The Corinthians are wise, strong, and honoured; the Apostles are fools, weak, and despised. St. Paul does not mean that the Corinthians are truly wise. He means that they are wise in their own eyes, and that the true wisdom looks like folly. He has already told them that the foolishness of God is wiser than men; and the weakness of God is stronger than men (1 Cor. 1:25). St. Thomas, commenting on these verses, says that the Apostles are called fools because they despise the things the world values and suffer the things the world flees, which to the world seems madness (Super I ad Corinthios, cap. 4, lect. 2). And what could look more foolish than a hermit who sends his brethren across the sea, with the money of the Order in their purses, to buy back strangers from slavery, and sometimes to stay behind in chains themselves when the money ran short?
Even unto this hour we both hunger and thirst, and are naked, and are buffeted, and have no fixed abode. Even unto this hour. St. Paul is not speaking of his past. He is writing from Ephesus, in the middle of his labours. Hunger, thirst, nakedness, blows, homelessness: these are the conditions of the Apostles’ life, not an accident in it. Notice that they are also the conditions which the Lord will name at the Last Judgment: I was hungry, I was thirsty, I was naked, I was a stranger, I was in prison (Matt. 25:35-36). The Apostles are living the life of the least of Christ’s brethren. And so are captives. The Church’s tradition counts among the corporal works of mercy to ransom the captive; St. Thomas, listing them in the old Latin verse, gives visito, poto, cibo, redimo, tego, colligo, condo: I visit, I give drink, I feed, I ransom, I clothe, I shelter, I bury (Summa Theologiæ II-II, q. 32). Redimo stands in the middle of the list. St. Felix built an Order around one word of it.
And we labour, working with our own hands. St. Paul supported himself as a tentmaker, so as not to be a burden to the churches. The hermit of Cerfroid lived by the same rule. The rule of the Trinitarians was austere: the friars fasted much, ate no meat on many days, and travelled on foot or on donkeys rather than horses, so that every coin they did not spend on themselves could go toward the ransom.
We are reviled, and we bless; we are persecuted, and we suffer it. We are blasphemed, and we entreat. Here is the heart of the Epistle. The Apostles do not answer evil with evil. They answer cursing with blessing, persecution with patience, blasphemy with gentle entreaty. They are doing exactly what Our Lord commanded: Bless them that curse you, and pray for them that persecute and calumniate you (Matt. 5:44). St. Chrysostom says that this is the real proof of an apostle, more than miracles: not that he suffers, since the wicked also suffer, but that he blesses those who make him suffer (Hom. in I Cor. 12.3). The ransoming friars went among men who held their brethren as slaves, and paid them, and spoke peaceably with them, and came back the next year to pay them again. They did not go with swords. They went with a purse and a blessing.
We are made as the refuse of this world, the offscouring of all even until now. The two Greek words are strong. Perikatharmata, the refuse, is what is swept up and thrown out; peripsēma, the offscouring, is what is scraped off a dirty pot. In the ancient world both words were also used of the wretched men who were cast out of a city, or killed, to carry away its pollution in time of plague: the scapegoats of the pagan cities. St. Ignatius of Antioch, being taken in chains to Rome to be thrown to the beasts, took up St. Paul’s word and applied it to himself. Writing to the Ephesians, he called himself their offscouring, and called his spirit the offscouring of the Cross: the lowest thing, offered for them (Ad Ephesios 8.1; 18.1). The word of contempt had become a word of love. The one who is thrown away for others is like Christ, who became a curse for us (Gal. 3:13).
I write not these things to confound you; but I admonish you as my dearest children. St. Paul does not end in bitterness. He has shamed the Corinthians, but he has done it as a father, not as an enemy. The whole passage has been a lesson in what it costs to be a Christian, written by a man who loves his readers enough to tell them the truth. For if you have ten thousand instructors in Christ, yet not many fathers (1 Cor. 4:15). St. Felix was a father of this kind: an old man who formed young men for a hard life, and sent them out to suffer, because he loved them, and loved the captives more than their comfort.
II. Nolite timere, pusillus grex: the Gospel
“At that time, Jesus said to his disciples: Fear not, little flock, for it hath pleased your Father to give you a kingdom. Sell what you possess and give alms. Make to yourselves bags which grow not old, a treasure in heaven which faileth not: where no thief approacheth, nor moth corrupteth. For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.” (Luke 12:32-34)
Fear not. The Gospel comes at the end of a long passage in St. Luke’s twelfth chapter on anxiety: the parable of the rich fool who built bigger barns and died that night, and the lilies of the field and the ravens who neither sow nor reap. Our Lord has just said, Seek ye first the kingdom of God and his justice, and all these things shall be added unto you (Luke 12:31). Now He turns to His disciples and tells them not to be afraid. The fear He means is the fear that makes men hoard: the fear of want, of the future, of losing what they have. The Epistle showed the Apostles hungry, naked, and homeless. The Gospel tells them that this need not frighten them.
Little flock. Pusillus grex. St. Bede asks why the Lord calls His flock little, and gives two answers. The first is that the elect are few compared with the multitude of the lost. The second is that they are little in humility: the Church grows great in number, but she must always remain small in her own eyes, so that she may be lifted up by her Father (In Lucæ evangelium expositio IV, on 12:32). St. Cyril of Alexandria says that the flock is little because the disciples were few and poor and despised among the Jews, and yet they were the flock of the Good Shepherd, and so they had nothing to fear (Commentarius in Lucam, Hom. 91). St. Ambrose sees in the little flock the image of the Apostles in the Epistle: weak, scorned, few, and yet given the kingdom (Expositio evangelii secundum Lucam VII, on 12:32).
The Trinitarians, too, were a little flock. They were never a great order like the Franciscans or the Dominicans. Their houses were small and their numbers modest. But they went where few others would go, into the slave markets of Algiers and Tunis and Fez, and the kingdom was given to them there.
For it hath pleased your Father to give you a kingdom. Complacuit Patri vestro. The reason for not fearing is not that the disciples are strong; the Epistle has just shown that they are weak. The reason is the good pleasure of the Father. He wants to give them the kingdom. Here is the first mention of the Holy Trinity, in a sense, in today’s Mass: the kingdom comes as the gift of the Father, who gives it through the Son who speaks these words. The Order of St. Felix bore the name of the Trinity, because it understood that every ransom is first the gift of the Father, who sent the Son to redeem captives, and of the Holy Ghost, the Spirit of the Lord … that hath anointed me … to preach deliverance to the captives (Luke 4:18).
Sell what you possess and give alms. Here is the command the Church chose for St. Felix. St. Cyprian wrote a whole treatise on alms, and in it he answered the man who says he cannot give much because he has children to provide for. Cyprian tells him that the safest inheritance for his children is to make God their guardian through alms, and that the money he hoards for them will be taken by thieves or the treasury or the moth, but what he gives to the poor is laid up where nothing can touch it (De opere et eleemosynis 16-19). St. Thomas teaches that almsgiving is commanded to everyone out of what is superfluous, and that to give up all one’s goods for God is the counsel of perfection, followed by those who enter religion (Summa Theologiæ II-II, q. 32; q. 186).
But the Fathers did not think only of giving to the hungry. St. Ambrose, Bishop of Milan, in the year 378, after the Goths had destroyed a Roman army at Adrianople and carried off thousands of captives, broke up and melted down the sacred vessels of his church to buy them back. When the Arians accused him of sacrilege, he answered in his book on the duties of the clergy. The Church, he said, has gold not to keep it but to spend it for those in need. What use is gold that does not help? Christ sent His Apostles without gold, and gathered His Church without gold. It is better to keep the living souls of men than to keep metal, and the Lord will not ask why we fed the hungry, but why we let them die while we kept our treasures. The finest adornment of the sacraments, he says, is the ransom of captives (De officiis ministrorum II.28.136-143). St. Ambrose calls this the highest kind of generosity, to redeem captives and especially to save them from a barbarous enemy who would destroy both body and soul (De officiis II.15.70).
St. Felix and St. John built an Order on Ambrose’s principle. The tertia pars of the Trinitarian rule was the sacred vessels of Milan made into a law of life.
Make to yourselves bags which grow not old, a treasure in heaven which faileth not. A purse wears out, and the money in it is spent. But the Lord speaks of purses that grow not old. St. Bede says these purses are our works of mercy, which keep their reward for ever (In Lucam IV, on 12:33). St. Augustine liked to say that the poor are our porters. If you had a great deal of goods to move to another country, he says, and porters came and offered to carry it all there for you at no charge, you would gladly give them everything. The poor are such porters: whatever you give them, they carry to heaven ahead of you, where you are going to live (Sermo 38.9; cf. Sermo 60.8). The captive ransomed in Algiers carried the third part of the Trinitarian revenues into heaven.
Where no thief approacheth, nor moth corrupteth. The rich fool’s barns were full, but this night do they require thy soul of thee (Luke 12:20). Death is the thief who takes everything. Only what has been given away is safe from him. St. John Chrysostom says that the man who hoards is like a man who keeps his treasure in a house that is about to burn down, when he could have sent it ahead to a safe house in the city where he is going (Homiliæ in Matthæum 20.2-3).
For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also. This last verse is the key to both readings. The heart follows the treasure. If our treasure is on earth, our heart will be chained to the earth; if it is in heaven, our heart will already live there. St. Augustine says that this is why the Church sings at Mass Sursum corda, Lift up your hearts: we must lift them to where our treasure is, so that they do not rot on the ground (Sermo 86.1; cf. Sermo 60.7). The Apostles in the Epistle could bear hunger, nakedness, and contempt because their hearts were not where their bodies were. Their treasure was in heaven, and their heart was with it.
And here is a deeper truth about captivity. A man in chains may be free in his heart, and a man in a palace may be a slave. St. Augustine says that the good man is free even if he is a slave, and the wicked man is a slave even if he is a king, for he serves as many masters as he has vices (De civitate Dei IV.3). The Trinitarians ransomed bodies; but they knew that the worst captivity is the soul’s bondage to sin, and that the first redemption is the one Christ wrought on the Cross.
III. The Mass as a whole: the arena and the ransom
St. Thomas built the Summa Theologiæ on the great circle of exitus and reditus: all things go out from God, and all things return to Him, through Christ, who as man is our way to God (Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue). Today’s Mass traces that circle as a story of captivity and ransom.
The going-out is the descent into the arena. The Apostles are set forth, sent out, made the last, condemned, exposed to the world. This is the shape of the Christian life in a fallen world: to be sent out into a place of exile, hunger, and contempt. But before the Apostles went out, the Son went out. He came forth from the Father and emptied himself, taking the form of a servant (Phil. 2:7); He became the spectacle on Calvary, the refuse of the world, thrown outside the city gate. He went down into the arena of our captivity, and paid for us with His blood. You are bought with a great price (1 Cor. 6:20). Every Trinitarian ransom was a small copy of that first descent.
The return is the treasure laid up in heaven. It hath pleased your Father to give you a kingdom. The little flock that went out into the arena is brought home and given the kingdom; the purses that do not grow old are found full; the heart that went ahead to its treasure is reunited with it. The captives came home over the sea; the friars who ransomed them came home to Cerfroid; and Felix, very old, went home on the fourth of November, 1212, to the Trinity whose glory he had served.
What closes the circle is the giving. The Apostles gave up everything and became a spectacle; the disciples are told to sell what they possess and give alms; and the Trinitarians gave a third of all they had, every year, for the freedom of strangers. This is the economy of the Gospel: we are freed in order to free others, ransomed in order to ransom. The motto of the Order says it in a line: Gloria tibi Trinitas, et captivis libertas. The glory of God and the freedom of captives are one thing.
IV. The Collects
Deus, qui beatum Felicem Confessorem tuum ex eremo ad munus redimendi captivos cælitus vocare dignatus es: præsta, quæsumus; ut per gratiam tuam ex peccatorum nostrorum captivitate, eius intercessione, liberati, ad cælestem patriam perducamur.
“O God, who didst vouchsafe to call blessed Felix, Thy Confessor, by a heavenly vocation from the wilderness to the work of ransoming captives: grant, we beseech Thee, that by Thy grace, through his intercession, we may be freed from the captivity of our sins and brought to our heavenly country.”
The Collect tells the whole of St. Felix’s life in a single clause: ex eremo ad munus redimendi captivos, from the hermitage to the work of ransom. It does not set the two against each other. The work came out of the solitude. Felix did not leave prayer to do good; prayer was where the good began, at the spring of Cerfroid, in three years of waiting with John of Matha before they went to Rome.
Then the Collect makes its request, and the request turns the ransom inward. We do not ask to be freed from the Moors. We ask to be freed ex peccatorum nostrorum captivitate, from the captivity of our sins. The Church reads the work of St. Felix as a sign of a greater redemption: every soul in sin is a captive, held by a master far crueller than any in the markets of Algiers, and only the ransom of Christ can set it free. Whosoever committeth sin is the servant of sin … If therefore the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed (John 8:34, 36). And the end of the prayer is the end of the journey: ad cælestem patriam, to our heavenly country. The captive’s deepest longing is to go home.
Laudis tibi, Domine, hostias immolamus in tuorum commemoratione Sanctorum: quibus nos et præsentibus exui malis confidimus et futuris.
“We offer to Thee, O Lord, sacrifices of praise in commemoration of Thy Saints: by whom we trust to be delivered both from present and from future evils.”
The Secret asks to be delivered, exui, literally stripped free, from evils present and to come. It is the language of a captive whose chains are taken off. The Sacrifice of the altar is the price of every ransom, the blood that bought the world.
Refecti cibo potuque cælesti, Deus noster, te supplices exoramus: ut, in cuius hæc commemoratione percepimus, eius muniamur et precibus.
“Refreshed with heavenly food and drink, O our God, we humbly beseech Thee that we may be strengthened by the prayers of him in whose commemoration we have received them.”
The Apostles in the Epistle hunger and thirst even unto this hour. In the Postcommunion we are fed with heavenly food and drink. The Eucharist is the bread of the little flock on its way through the arena: not yet the banquet of the kingdom, but its pledge.
V. A word for practice
Examine. Where is my treasure? If I want to know where my heart is, I need only ask what I worry about losing, what I spend my thoughts on, what I would find hardest to give away. Do I fear want so much that I hoard? Do I give alms out of my abundance only, or does my giving ever cost me something? When I am mocked or slighted, do I answer with a curse or with a blessing? And what sins hold me captive: a habit I have stopped fighting, a resentment I keep, a weakness I excuse? Have I asked Christ to ransom me from it, in the Sacrament of Penance?
Do. Set aside a fixed part of what you have, as the Trinitarians did, for those in need. It need not be a third; but let it be a portion you decide in advance, and keep to, and do not take back. Give some of it this week to those who are held captive today: there are still Christians imprisoned for their faith, and there are still men and women held in slavery and trafficking, and there are organizations, among them the Trinitarians themselves, that work for their freedom. Visit or write to someone in prison. And when someone speaks ill of you, bless them, in words if you can, and in prayer if you cannot.
Pray. The Collect of the day, asking to be freed from the captivity of your sins. And because this is the month of the Holy Souls, pray for the captives of Purgatory, who cannot ransom themselves and wait for the alms of our prayers and Masses. The old Trinitarian devotion of the Trisagion, the hymn Holy God, Holy Mighty One, Holy Immortal One, have mercy on us, is a good prayer to offer for them, and for all who are bound.
Aspiration. Ubi enim thesaurus vester est, ibi et cor vestrum erit. “For where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.”
Devote. St. Felix is a patron of the Trinitarian Order and of all works for the ransom of captives. Ask him to obtain for you the hermit’s love of prayer and the redeemer’s love of the captive. And remember that his Order was born under the patronage of the Blessed Trinity and of Our Lady, whom, the tradition says, he once found keeping the night Office with the angels. Tomorrow is her Presentation in the Temple: offer her this day’s alms, and ask her to present you to God.
If you wish to go deeper: the Lives of the Saints path tells the story of St. Felix of Valois and St. John of Matha, the hermitage at Cerfroid, the approval of the rule by Innocent III, and the first redemptions in North Africa; it sets them beside St. Peter Nolasco and St. Raymond Nonnatus of the Mercedarian Order, and Our Lady of Ransom, whose feast we kept in September. The Church History path follows the long story of Christian captivity in the Mediterranean, from the Goths of Adrianople and the ransoms of St. Ambrose to the Barbary corsairs and the redemption of Cervantes. The Theology and Doctrine path treats St. Thomas on the works of mercy and the counsel of poverty, and the Fathers on Christ’s redemption as a ransom. The Spiritual Practices and Devotions path takes up almsgiving as a fixed rule of life, devotion to the Most Holy Trinity, and prayer for the Holy Souls. The Sacred Liturgy path considers the Common of Confessors and the Church’s use of proper lessons to fit a saint’s particular vocation.
Sources. Scripture is cited from the Douay-Rheims, with the Vulgate. The Fathers are given in paraphrase with their loci: St. John Chrysostom, Homiliæ in epistulam I ad Corinthios 12 and Homiliæ in Matthæum 20; St. Cyprian, Epistula 76 and De opere et eleemosynis; St. Ignatius of Antioch, Ad Ephesios 8 and 18; St. Ambrose, De officiis ministrorum II.15 and II.28, and Expositio evangelii secundum Lucam VII; St. Augustine, Sermones 38, 60, and 86, and De civitate Dei IV.3; St. Cyril of Alexandria, Commentarius in Lucam; St. Bede, In Lucæ evangelium expositio IV. St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiæ I, q. 2, prologue, and II-II, qq. 32 and 186; Super I ad Corinthios, cap. 4. For St. Felix: the Roman Breviary and the Roman Martyrology; Butler’s Lives of the Saints; the Catholic Encyclopedia; the rule of the Order of the Most Holy Trinity approved by Innocent III (1198).
Gloria tibi Trinitas, et captivis libertas.